A Systematic Review of Echo Chamber Research: Comparative Analysis of Conceptualizations, Operationalizations, and Varying Outcomes
Authors:
- David HartmannDHDavid Hartmann
- Lena PohlmannLPLena Pohlmann
- Sonja Mei WangSWSonja Mei Wang
- Bettina BerendtBBBettina Berendt
Preprint
Abstract
This systematic review synthesizes current research on echo chambers and filter bubbles to highlight the reasons for the dissent in echo chamber research on the existence, antecedents, and effects of the phenomenon. The review of 112 studies reveals that the lack of consensus in echo chamber research is based on different conceptualizations and operationalizations of echo chambers. While studies that have conceptualized echo chambers with homophily and utilized data-driven computational social science (CSS) methods have confirmed the echo chamber hypothesis and polarization effects in social media, content exposure studies and surveys that have explored the full spectrum of media exposure have rejected it. Most of these studies have been conducted in the United States, and the review emphasizes the need for a more comprehensive understanding of how echo chambers work in systems with more than two parties and outside the Global North. To advance our understanding of this phenomenon, future research should prioritize conducting more cross-platform studies, considering algorithmic filtering changes through continuous auditing, and examining the causal direction of the association between polarization, fragmentation, and the establishment of online echo chambers. The review also provides the advantages and disadvantages of different operationalizations and makes recommendations for studies in the European Union (EU), which will become possible with the upcoming Digital Services Act (DSA). Overall, this systematic review contributes to the ongoing scholarly discussion on the existence, antecedents, and effects of echo chambers and filter bubbles.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 180 references indexed in Scilit:
- Birds of a Feather Get Angrier Together: Social Media News Use and Social Media Political Homophily as Antecedents of Political AngerPolitical Behavior, 2023
- Which academic search systems are suitable for systematic reviews or meta‐analyses? Evaluating retrieval qualities of Google Scholar, PubMed, and 26 other resourcesResearch Synthesis Methods, 2019
- The End of the Habermassian Ideal? Political Communication on Twitter During the 2017 Turkish Constitutional ReferendumPolicy & Internet, 2019
- The Role of Political Activity in the Formation of Online Identity BubblesPolicy & Internet, 2019
- Quantifying Biases in Online Information ExposureJournal of the Association for Information Science and Technology, 2018
- The Power of Default on Reddit: A General Model to Measure the Influence of Information IntermediariesPolicy & Internet, 2017
- Measuring and moderating opinion polarization in social networksData Mining and Knowledge Discovery, 2017
- Searching for grey literature for systematic reviews: challenges and benefitsResearch Synthesis Methods, 2013
- Handbook of Causal Analysis for Social Research2013
- The existence of publication bias and risk factors for its occurrenceJAMA, 1990