Research on inequality in South Africa emphasizes the continuation of the historically produced inequalities along racial categories. Based on an ethnography of the desegregation process of student residences in contemporary South Africa, the authors show how certain types of white students find themselves in a situation in which their endowment with economic and cultural capital constitutes a privilege, while their ethnoracial positioning in current discourses and institutional regulations warrants their decentering and withdrawal. The authors empirically show how the students’ habitus corroborates or mitigates this positioning through the different ways in which they relate to ethnicity and race. The authors extend Bourdieu’s notion of a ‘cleft’ or ‘divided habitus’ and distinguish three ideal-typical types of habitus: a broken habitus, a bi-cameral habitus, and a hybrid habitus. The authors demonstrate how particularly a broken (and to some extent a hybrid) habitus constitutes a position of partial privilege.