Error Span Annotation: A Balanced Approach for Human Evaluation of Machine Translation

Authors:
  • TKTom Kocmi
    Tom Kocmi
  • VZVilém Zouhar
    Vilém Zouhar
  • EAEleftherios Avramidis
    Eleftherios Avramidis
  • RGRoman Grundkiewicz
    Roman Grundkiewicz
  • MKMarzena Karpinska
    Marzena Karpinska
  • MPMaja Popović
    Maja Popović
  • MSMrinmaya Sachan
    Mrinmaya Sachan
  • MSMariya Shmatova
    Mariya Shmatova

Abstract
High-quality Machine Translation (MT) evaluation relies heavily on human judgments. Comprehensive error classification methods, such as Multidimensional Quality Metrics (MQM), are expensive as they are time-consuming and can only be done by experts, whose availability may be limited especially for low-resource languages. On the other hand, just assigning overall scores, like Direct Assessment (DA), is simpler and faster and can be done by translators of any level, but are less reliable. In this paper, we introduce Error Span Annotation (ESA), a human evaluation protocol which combines the continuous rating of DA with the high-level error severity span marking of MQM. We validate ESA by comparing it to MQM and DA for 12 MT systems and one human reference translation (English to German) from WMT23. The results show that ESA offers faster and cheaper annotations than MQM at the same quality level, without the requirement of expensive MQM experts.