Antibiotic Resistance, Meat Consumption and the Harm Principle
Open Access
- 24 October 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Ethics, Policy & Environment
- Vol. 26 (1) , 53-68
Abstract
This paper vindicates using the harm principle (HP) to justify restricting consumer’s access to meat products in light of the impact that it has on the development of antibiotic resistance (ABR). In particular, the study claims that, since an individual instance of consumption, or purchase of meat, meaningfully contributes to the development of ABR in farming environments, a state intervention limiting consumer freedom would be legitimate. The causal impact of individuals in greater-scale problems has long been debated and dismissed as not relevant. The study analyzed two possible formulations of the inconsequentialist objection. While the first formulation, which maintains that individuals have no impact, can be rejected independently of the context of application, rejecting the second formulation, which maintains that this impact is insufficient to warrant applying HP, is more difficult. In order to successfully respond to this version of inconsequentialism, the paper vindicates the value of considering ABR and ABR-related harm within a more traditional expected utility arguments.Keywords
Funding Information
- Vetenskapsrådet
This publication has 44 references indexed in Scilit:
- Antibiotic resistance in the environment: a link to the clinic?Current Opinion in Microbiology, 2010
- Climate change and the duties of the advantagedCritical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy, 2010
- Combating Resistance: The Case for a Global Antibiotics TreatyPublic Health Ethics, 2010
- It's Not My2005
- Tobacco taxation and public health: ethical problems, policy responsesSocial Science & Medicine, 2005
- Puppies, Pigs, and People: Eating Meat and Marginal CasesPhilosophical Perspectives, 2004
- Ethical Obligations in a Tragedy of the CommonsEnvironmental Values, 2003
- Antimicrobial Use in Animal Feed — Time to StopNew England Journal of Medicine, 2001
- Causation as InfluenceThe Journal of Philosophy, 2000
- CausationThe Journal of Philosophy, 1973