Sharing Four Biscuits Between Three People: An Illustrative Example of How Mathematics is Intertwined with Human Values
Open Access
- 1 January 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Claremont Colleges Library in Journal of Humanistic Mathematics
- Vol. 14 (1) , 74-93
Abstract
Despite convincing arguments by mathematicians, philosophers, sociologists and machine learning practitioners to the contrary, there remains a widespread notion amongst many members of the general public (and some practitioners) that mathematics is neutral, that it is free from human values. One reason why this notion persists is that we lack clear-cut examples that demonstrate how mathematics and values are intertwined. In this paper, we offer one such example. In particular, we show that when sharing four biscuits between three people, several possible mathematical and ethical frameworks can be used. We demon- strate that different solutions—hiding one biscuit, arbitrarily sharing the extra biscuit, randomizing allocation, dividing the extra biscuit into three parts, and successively dividing it into smaller and smaller parts—involve different mathematical methods and evoke different human values. We discuss the construction of quantum biscuit splitting devices and the use of machine learning to divide biscuits. We argue that the multitude of different mathematically-correct solutions to this problem (each with its own ethical justification) might influence the values held by practicing mathematicians. The example we propose here has been used in teaching to help students understand why mathematics cannot be cleanly separated from human values.Keywords
This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit:
- Wicked Problems in Public Policy2022
- Algorithmic injustice: a relational ethics approachPatterns, 2021
- Roles for computing in social change2020
- Making the Subjective Objective: Machine Learning and RhinoplastyAesthetic Surgery Journal, 2019
- Do Inheritance Customs Affect Political and Social Inequality?American Journal of Political Science, 2019
- Rethinking Mathematics Teaching in Liberia: Realistic Mathematics EducationChildhood Education, 2017
- Beyond Subjective and Objective in StatisticsJournal of the Royal Statistical Society Series A: Statistics in Society, 2017
- Sustainable Development as a Wicked Problem2012
- Wicked problems revisitedDesign Studies, 2005
- Inductive Risk and Values in SciencePhilosophy of Science, 2000