Conference presentation to publication: a retrospective study evaluating quality of abstracts and journal articles in medical education research
Open Access
- 9 November 2017
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Education
- Vol. 17 (1) , 193
Abstract
There is little evidence regarding the comparative quality of abstracts and articles in medical education research. The Medical Education Research Study Quality Instrument (MERSQI), which was developed to evaluate the quality of reporting in medical education, has strong validity evidence for content, internal structure, and relationships to other variables. We used the MERSQI to compare the quality of reporting for conference abstracts, journal abstracts, and published articles. This is a retrospective study of all 46 medical education research abstracts submitted to the Society of General Internal Medicine 2009 Annual Meeting that were subsequently published in a peer-reviewed journal. We compared MERSQI scores of the abstracts with scores for their corresponding published journal abstracts and articles. Comparisons were performed using the signed rank test. Overall MERSQI scores increased significantly for published articles compared with conference abstracts (11.33 vs 9.67; P < .001) and journal abstracts (11.33 vs 9.96; P < .001). Regarding MERSQI subscales, published articles had higher MERSQI scores than conference abstracts in the domains of sampling (1.59 vs 1.34; P = .006), data analysis (3.00 vs 2.43; P < .001), and validity of evaluation instrument (1.04 vs 0.28; P < .001). Published articles also had higher MERSQI scores than journal abstracts in the domains of data analysis (3.00 vs 2.70; P = .004) and validity of evaluation instrument (1.04 vs 0.26; P < .001). To our knowledge, this is the first study to compare the quality of medical education abstracts and journal articles using the MERSQI. Overall, the quality of articles was greater than that of abstracts. However, there were no significant differences between abstracts and articles for the domains of study design and outcomes, which indicates that these MERSQI elements may be applicable to abstracts. Findings also suggest that abstract quality is generally preserved from original presentation to publication.Keywords
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- Method and reporting quality in health professions education research: a systematic reviewMedical Education, 2011
- Predictive Validity Evidence for Medical Education Research Study Quality Instrument Scores: Quality of Submissions to JGIM’s Medical Education Special IssueJournal of General Internal Medicine, 2008
- Association Between Funding and Quality of Published Medical Education ResearchJAMA, 2007
- Full publication of results initially presented in abstractsCochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2007
- Strengthening Structured Abstracts for Education Research: The Need for Claim-Based Structured AbstractsEducational Researcher, 2007
- Quality of Abstracts of Papers Reporting Original Cost-Effectiveness AnalysesMedical Decision Making, 2005
- Why We Need a Structured Abstract in Education ResearchEducational Researcher, 2004
- Unpublished Research From a Medical Specialty MeetingJAMA, 1998
- Factors Influencing Publication of Research ResultsJAMA, 1992
- Publication bias in clinical researchThe Lancet, 1991