Comparison of Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis Methods Under Comprehensive Sensitivity Analysis
Open Access
- 11 July 2025
- journal article
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Access
- Vol. 13, 128122-128138
Abstract
In many contemporary decision-making environments, practitioners must navigate complex problems characterized by multiple, conflicting criteria. Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis (MCDA) methods have become essential tools for structuring such evaluations, enabling more transparent and data-driven recommendations. However, their practical usefulness depends on both their theoretical foundations and their ability to perform reliably under uncertain or changing input data. Despite their widespread integration into Decision Support Systems (DSS), there remains a lack of systematic investigation into how robust different MCDA methods are when exposed to variability in the decision data. This study addresses this gap by investigating the stability and sensitivity of four selected used MCDA methods, Root Assessment Method (RAM), Complex Proportional Assessment (COPRAS), Technique for Order Preference by Similarity to an Ideal Solution (TOPSIS), and Measurement of Alternatives and Ranking according to Compromise Solution (MARCOS). These methods were chosen based on their diverse computational assumptions and approaches to preference calculation, providing a representative basis for comparing stability across different methodological principles. The analysis employs the Comprehensive Sensitivity Analysis Method (COMSAM), a systematic framework that introduces simultaneous perturbations into the decision matrix to simulate real-world uncertainty. Through both simulation experiments and a practical facility location problem, the study reveals significant differences in method stability. RAM demonstrated the highest robustness, maintaining consistent preference rankings, while TOPSIS was most sensitive to matrix fluctuations. The findings highlight the critical role of method selection in DSS design, particularly in dynamic environments. The study contributes a structured comparative framework and empirical benchmarks that support the development of reliable MCDA-based decision tools under conditions of uncertainty.Keywords
This publication has 59 references indexed in Scilit:
- Prioritisation of strategies for the adoption of organic agriculture using BWM and fuzzy CoCoSoSoft Computing, 2023
- Fermatean fuzzy multi-criteria decision-making based on Spearman rank correlation coefficientGranular Computing, 2023
- New cosine similarity and distance measures for Fermatean fuzzy sets and TOPSIS approachKnowledge and Information Systems, 2022
- Risk assessment in livestock supply chain using the MCDM method: a case of emerging economyEnvironmental Science and Pollution Research, 2022
- Evaluating appropriate communication technology for smart grid by using a comprehensive decision-making approach fuzzy TOPSISSoft Computing, 2022
- An integrated ranking approach based on group multi-criteria decision making and sensitivity analysis to evaluate charging stations under sustainabilityEnvironment, Development and Sustainability, 2022
- Why Does the Choice of Normalization Technique Matter in Decision-Making2022
- Identification of the Groundwater Potential Recharge Zones Using MCDM Models: Full Consistency Method (FUCOM), Best Worst Method (BWM) and Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP)Water Resources Management, 2021
- A New Coefficient of Rankings Similarity in Decision-Making Problems2020
- On Two Classes of Weighted Rank Correlation Measures Deriving from the Spearman’s ρ2013