The societal construction of ‘boys’ underachievement’ in educational policies: a cross‐national comparison
- 22 March 2011
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Education Policy
- Vol. 26 (2) , 161-180
Abstract
Through the example of what is now known in a large part of the Anglo‐saxon world as the boys’ underachievement debate, this paper explores the construction of gender issues, which underpins educational policies in England and France. It argues that the formation of particular questions as ‘policy issues’ bears limited relation to what happens on the ground, yet is contingent on societal contexts. For example, while England and France share similar patterns in terms of the differential achievement of boys and girls, in the former the boys’ underachievement debate is prominent, but in the latter it is non‐existent. This supports the view that the emergence of the boys’ underachievement debate is not related to a ‘grounded reality’. Rather, the debate appears embedded in the discursive construction of gender and education and, more generally, of notions of citizenship and equality/difference. These findings provide a strong case in favour of a reflexive approach to equality matters in educational policy making. They also suggest that the analysis of what is constructed as a key issue in policy circles represents a rich terrain for feminist analysis, and they highlight that national frameworks continue to structure the thinking on equality issues.Keywords
This publication has 40 references indexed in Scilit:
- ‘They do not relate to Black people like us’: Black teachers as role models for Black pupilsJournal of Education Policy, 2009
- Pedagogies of indifferenceInternational Journal of Inclusive Education, 2007
- The New Teacher Education: For Better or for Worse?Educational Researcher, 2005
- Réussite scolaire des filles et des garçons et socialisation différentielle des sexes à l’écoleRecherches féministes, 2005
- Seeing things differently: teachers' constructions of underachievementGender and Education, 2004
- The 'feminisation of schooling' or 're-masculinising' primary education?[1]International Studies in Sociology of Education, 2002
- Masculinity, inequality and post-school opportunities: disrupting oppositional politics about boys' educationInternational Journal of Inclusive Education, 2001
- Modernist Reductionism or Post-structuralist Relativism: Can we move on? An Evaluation of the Arguments in Relation to Feminist Educational ResearchGender and Education, 1999
- Troubling Boys and Disturbing Discourses on Masculinity and Schooling: A feminist exploration of current debates and interventions concerning boys in schoolGender and Education, 1999
- Social Class, Educational Opportunity and Equal Entitlement: Dilemmas of schooling in England and FranceComparative Education, 1997