This study investigated the partial mediating effect of defensive silence between workplace ostracism and emotional exhaustion, explained through Social Identity Theory. It collected time-lagged data at two measurement points from 320 employees, working in service sector organizations of Pakistan. The study found that employees appraise workplace ostracism as a social identity threat that effects their relational and efficacy needs. They try to manage their sense of futility or control, through a pro-self response, defensive silence. From a social identity perspective, this focus on oneself rather than ones’ group, detracts their ability to cope with emotional demands and leads to emotional exhaustion. Overall, our results demonstrate that emotional exhaustion is a function of workplace ostracism and defensive silence and offer several direct as well as indirect options. One path involves actions that discourage workplace ostracism through various human resource functions. Another step pertains to defensive silence which could be put off by a suggestion system that offers psychological safety to employees. The present study overcomes the limitations of emotional exhaustion research which typically relies on approach-oriented reactions and instead, brings in a versatile perspective that offers social identity perspective. Alongside the self- oriented (defensive silence), it focuses on other-oriented behavior (prosocial silence) and explores their differential reasons for causing emotional exhaustion.