The materiality of discourse as oxymoron: A challenge to critical rhetoric
Author:
- 1 September 1994
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Western Journal of Communication
- Vol. 58 (3) , 141-163
Abstract
Recent rhetorical theory has adopted two versions—variously idealist and relativist—of the proposition that discourse is influential in or even constitutive of social and material “reality.”; This idea, which underpins much critical communication scholarship, I am calling the “materiality of discourse hypothesis.”; This essay documents and criticizes the idealism and relativism of the materiality of discourse idea in postmodernist and post‐Marxist rhetorical theories, illustrates the critique with an extended critical analysis of Persian Gulf War news coverage, and defends materialist ideology criticism as an alternative to a critical rhetoric that has become increasingly affirmative of the social order and detached from reality.Keywords
This publication has 41 references indexed in Scilit:
- The limits of interpretation: Ambivalence and the stereotype inSpenser: For hireCritical Studies in Mass Communication, 1992
- Reflections on an argument that won't go away: Or, a turn of the ideological screwQuarterly Journal of Speech, 1992
- Commitment totelos—a sustained critical rhetoricCommunication Monographs, 1992
- At the ideological frontCommunication Studies, 1991
- The “lost” passages ofpermanence and changeCommunication Studies, 1991
- Not yet the post‐imperialist eraCritical Studies in Mass Communication, 1991
- Critical rhetoric: Theory and praxisCommunication Monographs, 1989
- The rhetorical limits of polysemyCritical Studies in Mass Communication, 1989
- Relocating the site of the audienceCritical Studies in Mass Communication, 1988
- Television: Polysemy and popularityCritical Studies in Mass Communication, 1986