Occupational Relevance and Body Mass Bias in Military Physical Fitness Tests
- 1 August 2008
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise
- Vol. 40 (8) , 1538-1545
Abstract
Recent evidence makes a compelling case that US Army, Navy, and Air Force health-related physical fitness tests penalize larger, not just fatter, service members. As a result, they tend to receive lower scores than their lighter counterparts, the magnitude of which can be explained by biologic scaling laws. Larger personnel, on the other hand, tend to be better performers of work-related fitness tasks such as load carriage, heavy lifting, and materiel handling. This has been explained by empirical evidence that lean body mass and lean body mass to dead mass ratio (dead mass = fat mass and external load to be carried/lifted) are more potent determinants of performance of these military tasks than the fitness test events such as push-ups, sit-ups, or 2-mile-distance run time. Because promotions are based, in part, on fitness test performance, lighter personnel have an advancement advantage, although they tend to be poorer performers on many tests of work-related fitness. Several strategies have been proposed to rectify this incongruence including balanced tests, scaled scores, and correction factors--yet most need large-scale validation. Because nearly all subjects in such research have been men, future investigations should focus on women and elucidate the feasibility of universal physical fitness tests for all that include measures of health- and work-related fitness while imposing no systematic body mass bias.Keywords
This publication has 27 references indexed in Scilit:
- Prediction of Simulated Battlefield Physical Performance from Field-Expedient TestsMilitary Medicine, 2008
- Generic task-related occupational requirements for Royal Naval personnelOccupational Medicine, 2002
- Muscle force and muscle torque in humans require different methods when adjusting for differences in body sizeEuropean Journal of Applied Physiology, 2002
- Muscle Strength TestingSports Medicine, 2002
- Assessment of physical fitness for occupations encompassing load-carriage tasksOccupational Medicine, 2001
- Modeling the influence of body size onV˙o2 peak: effects of model choice and body compositionJournal of Applied Physiology, 1999
- Body mass scaling of peak oxygen uptake in 20- to 79-yr-old adultsMedicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 1997
- Allometric modeling does not determine a dimensionless power function ratio for maximal muscular functionJournal of Applied Physiology, 1997
- Normalizing strength for body size differences in older adultsMedicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 1997
- SCALING OF PUSH-UP, SIT-UP AND TWO-MILE RUN PERFORMANCES BY BODY WEIGHT AND FAT-FREE WEIGHT IN YOUNG, FIT MEN 1089Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 1996