Implications of announced phase II national allocation plans for the EU ETS

Authors:
  • FFFederico Ferrario
    Federico Ferrario
  • KHKristina Holmgren
    Kristina Holmgren
  • GPGabriella Pal
    Gabriella Pal
  • MGMichael Grubb
    Michael Grubb
  • FMFelix Matthes
    Felix Matthes
  • KRKaroline Rogge
    Karoline Rogge
  • MSMisato Sato
    Misato Sato
  • JSJoachim Schleich
    Joachim Schleich

Abstract
We quantified the volume of free allowances that different National Allocation Plans proposed to allocate to existing and new installations, with specific reference to the power sector. Most countries continue to allocate based on historic emissions, contrary to hopes for improved allocation methods, with allocations to installations frequently based on 2005 emission data; this may strengthen belief in the private sector that emissions in the coming years will influence their subsequent allowance allocation. Allocations to new installations provide high and frequently fuel differentiated subsidies, risking significant distortions to investment choices. Thus in addition to being numerically weak in aggregate, proposed allocation plans reveal continuing if diverse problems, including perverse incentives. Ensuring the effectiveness of EU ETS in the coming years will require credible evidence to the private sector that free allowance allocation will be drastically reduced post-2012, or these problems otherwise addressed.