Understanding without Explanation: A Still Open Issue
Open Access
- 31 October 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by University of Warsaw in Filozofia Nauki
- Vol. 29 (3) , 80-106
Abstract
This paper takes a stance in the debate concerning scientific understanding. It claims that the case for a specific type of understanding, understanding without explanation (UwE), is still open, despite the tendency in the current literature that might suggest otherwise. The paper begins by situating the distinction between an explanatory and non-explanatory understanding in the debate on understanding by introducing Lipton’s account of UwE. The paper then discusses the significance of Lipton’s proposals for the debate and argues that Kelp’s interpretation does not exhaust the challenge they pose to any theory of understanding. The paper then examines the best articulated critique of Lipton’s account provided by Khalifa and rejects it as inadequate. It ends by sketching out a list of positive reasons that support the continued examination of UwE.Keywords
This publication has 23 references indexed in Scilit:
- Understanding in epistemology and philosophy of science: a complicated relationshipMetascience, 2018
- Understanding, Explanation, and Scientific Knowledge2017
- Understanding phenomenaSynthese, 2015
- No understanding without explanationStudies in History and Philosophy of Science, 2013
- Introduction: philosophy of science in practiceEuropean Journal for Philosophy of Science, 2011
- A Contextual Approach to Scientific UnderstandingSynthese, 2005
- The Value of Knowledge and the Pursuit of Understanding2003
- Outline of a theory of scientific understandingSynthese, 1994
- Context of discovery and context of justificationStudies in History and Philosophy of Science, 1987
- Studies in the Logic of ExplanationPhilosophy of Science, 1948