This article argues through the use of a case study that the current political climate in the United Kingdom is not conducive to religion-related dialog. First, there is a contested notion over whether the classroom is a space for religion-related dialog. Second, classrooms are affected by the national context of the duty placed upon teachers to prevent extremism. This reduces the sense of the classroom as a safe space as it undermines the trust pupils, particularly Muslim pupils, have in open discussion and increases the sense of anxiety felt by teachers that, in opening up discussion, they risk having to report extremist content.