The Target-to-Foils Shift in Simultaneous and Sequential Lineups.
Authors:
- Steven E. ClarkSCSteven E. Clark
- Sherrie L. DaveySDSherrie L. Davey
- 1 April 2005
- journal article
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Law and Human Behavior
- Vol. 29 (2) , 151-172
Abstract
A theoretical cornerstone in eyewitness identification research is the proposition that witnesses, in making decisions from standard simultaneous lineups, make relative judgments. The present research considers two sources of support for this proposal. An experiment by G. L. Wells (1993) showed that if the target is removed from a lineup, witnesses shift their responses to pick foils, rather than rejecting the lineups, a result we will term a target-to-foils shift. Additional empirical support is provided by results from sequential lineups which typically show higher accuracy than simultaneous lineups, presumably because of a decrease in the use of relative judgments in making identification decisions. The combination of these two lines of research suggests that the target-to-foils shift should be reduced in sequential lineups relative to simultaneous lineups. Results of two experiments showed an overall advantage for sequential lineups, but also showed a target-to-foils shift equal in size for simultaneous and sequential lineups. Additional analyses indicated that the target-to-foils shift in sequential lineups was moderated in part by an order effect and was produced with (Experiment 2) or without (Experiment 1) a shift in decision criterion. This complex pattern of results suggests that more work is needed to understand the processes which underlie decisions in simultaneous and sequential lineups.Keywords
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- A memory and decision model for eyewitness identificationApplied Cognitive Psychology, 2003
- Simultaneous and sequential lineups: decision processes of accurate and inaccurate eyewitnessesApplied Cognitive Psychology, 2001
- Selecting lineup foils in eyewitness identification experiments: Experimental control and real-world simulation.Law and Human Behavior, 2001
- Lineup administrators' expectations: Their impact on eyewitness confidence.Law and Human Behavior, 2001
- Applying applied research: selling the sequential line-upApplied Cognitive Psychology, 1999
- Simultaneous lineups, sequential lineups, and showups: Eyewitness identification decisions of adults and children.Law and Human Behavior, 1997
- Distinguishing accurate from inaccurate eyewitness identifications via inquiries about decision processes.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1994
- Biased lineups: Sequential presentation reduces the problem.Journal of Applied Psychology, 1991
- Improving the reliability of eyewitness identification: Lineup construction and presentation.Journal of Applied Psychology, 1988
- Improving eyewitness identifications from lineups: Simultaneous versus sequential lineup presentation.Journal of Applied Psychology, 1985