Brush Cytology, Forceps Biopsy, or Endoscopic Ultrasound-Guided Sampling for Diagnosis of Bile Duct Cancer: A Meta-Analysis
Authors:
- 14 July 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Digestive Diseases and Sciences
- Vol. 67 (7) , 3284-3297
Abstract
Endoscopic sampling is essential for tissue diagnosis of cholangiocarcinoma (CCA). To evaluate and compare the diagnostic sensitivities of endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography-guided brush cytology biopsy, and endoscopic ultrasound-guided fine needle aspiration (EUS-FNA) in patients with CCA. A comprehensive literature search through multiple databases was conducted for articles published between January 1995 and August 2020. The pooled rates of sensitivity for the diagnosis of CCA and of adverse events were compared among brushing, biopsy, brushing & biopsy, and EUS-FNA. In total, 1123 patients with CCA (32 studies), 719 patients (20 studies), 358 patients (13 studies), and 422 patients (17 studies) were tested by brushing, biopsy, brushing & biopsy, and EUS-FNA, respectively. The pooled diagnostic sensitivity was 56.0% (95% confidence interval (CI) 48.8–63.1%, I2 = 83.0%) with brushing, 67.0% (95% CI 60.2–73.5%, I2 = 72.5%) with biopsy, 70.7% (95% CI 64.1–76.8%, I2 = 42.7%) with brushing & biopsy, and 73.6% (95% CI 64.7–81.5%, I2 = 74.7%) with EUS-FNA. The diagnostic sensitivity was significantly lower for brushing than for biopsy, brushing & biopsy, or EUS-FNA. No significant difference was noted in diagnostic sensitivities among biopsy, brushing & biopsy, and EUS-FNA. Adverse events were comparable between the groups. Intraductal biopsy, brushing & biopsy, and EUS-FNA had comparable efficacy and safety for the diagnosis of CCA. Brushing was the least sensitive diagnostic tool compared with intraductal biopsy or EUS-FNA. Given the modest diagnostic sensitivities of intraductal biopsy and EUS-FNA in the diagnosis of CCA, further studies for complementing these techniques with biomarkers may be needed.Keywords
This publication has 92 references indexed in Scilit:
- Detection of IGF2BP3, HOXB7, and NEK2 mRNA Expression in Brush Cytology Specimens as a New Diagnostic Tool in Patients with Biliary StricturesPLOS ONE, 2012
- Whole genome RNA expression profiling of endoscopic biliary brushings provides data suitable for biomarker discovery in cholangiocarcinomaJournal of Hepatology, 2012
- Clinical diagnosis and staging of cholangiocarcinomaNature Reviews Gastroenterology & Hepatology, 2011
- Trans-peritoneal fine needle aspiration biopsy of hilar cholangiocarcinoma is associated with disease disseminationHPB, 2011
- Role of EUS for preoperative evaluation of cholangiocarcinoma: a large single-center experienceGastrointestinal Endoscopy, 2011
- Comparison of KRAS Mutation Analysis and FISH for Detecting Pancreatobiliary Tract Cancer in Cytology Specimens Collected During Endoscopic Retrograde CholangiopancreatographyThe Journal of Molecular Diagnostics, 2010
- Critical evaluation of the Newcastle-Ottawa scale for the assessment of the quality of nonrandomized studies in meta-analysesEuropean Journal of Epidemiology, 2010
- The Significance of p53 and K-ras Immunocytochemical Staining in the Diagnosis of Malignant Biliary Obstruction by Brush Cytology during ERCPGut and Liver, 2010
- Diagnosis of biliary tract and ampullary carcinomasJournal of Hepato-Biliary-Pancreatic Surgery, 2008
- Endoscopic ultrasound‐guided FNA biopsy of bile duct and gallbladder: analysis of 53 casesCytopathology, 2006