An Investigation of the Relationship Between Actual and Apparent Gasoline Thickness in a Uniform Sand Aquifer
Authors:
- 1 September 1994
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Groundwater
- Vol. 32 (5) , 708-718
Abstract
A common effort involved in the remediation of contamination by petroleum hydrocarbons in porous media is the monitoring and volume estimation of the immiscible hydrocarbon fluid. The apparent free product thickness indicated by a standard monitoring well is typically much greater than the actual free product thickness in the surrounding soil. This results in significant errors in estimates of drainable fluid (product) volume, which in turn leads to inaccuracies (i.e., over design, improper pump sizing, etc.) with remediation system design. An equation to predict actual thickness was developed using heterogeneous fluid flow mechanics and hydrostatics. This equation is: t g = t(l – S g ) ‐ h a , where t g = actual formation free product thickness, t = apparent (well bore product) thickness, S g = specific gravity of petroleum hydrocarbon (gasoline in this research), and h a = distance between the ground‐water table and the free product in the formation. The developed theory was compared to data collected from a physical model which simulated field conditions. The theory was used to estimate product thickness in the model, and then these estimates were statistically tested for accuracy. The theoretical slope, (1 – S g ), was not statistically different from the regression slope at test levels of α= 0.05 and α= 0.01, while the theoretical intercept (h a ) was statistically different at α– 0.05 and α– 0.01. The discrepancy between the theoretical intercept and the regression intercept was probably due to either an incorrect assumption that h a = h c (h c = average wetting capillary rise), or an incorrect laboratory measurement of h c . The effects of water‐table fluctuations were also studied. A rising water table caused a decrease in apparent thickness and an increase in actual thickness, and vice versa. No theoretical equation was developed for the effects of water‐table fluctuations, but it was reasoned that hysteresis of the saturation curve and adsorption were the primary factors in the observed trends. Finally, the developed theoretical equation was compared to the results of previously published predictive methods and experiments. The comparison was made by calculating percent error and using a chi‐square statistic. The developed theory was found to be the best predictor of actual product thickness for both laboratory data sets used.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- DISCUSSION OF “Estimation of Free Hydrocarbon Volume from Fluid Levels in Monitoring Wells,” by R. J. Lenhard and J. C. Parker, January‐February 1990 issue, v. 28, no. 1, pp. 57–67 and “Volume Estimation of Light Nonaqueous Phase Liquids in Porous Media,” by A. M. Farr, R. J. Houghtalen, and D. B. McWhorter, January‐February 1990 issue, v. 28, no. 1, pp. 48–56Groundwater, 1990
- Estimation of Free Hydrocarbon Volume from Fluid Levels in Monitoring WellsGroundwater, 1990
- Volume Estimation of Light Nonaqueous Phase Liquids in Porous MediaGroundwater, 1990
- Limitations of Monitoring Wells for the Detection and Quantification of Petroleum Products in Soils and AquifersGroundwater Monitoring & Remediation, 1989
- Volume Determination and Recoverability of Free HydrocarbonGroundwater Monitoring & Remediation, 1989
- A parametric model for constitutive properties governing multiphase flow in porous mediaWater Resources Research, 1987
- Underground Storage Tank Monitoring: Observation Well Based SystemsGroundwater Monitoring & Remediation, 1986
- Considerations on Water, Oil and Air in Porous MediaWater Science & Technology, 1985
- Migration of Organic Fluids Immiscible with Water in the Unsaturated Zone1984
- Ground‐Water Pollution From GasolineGroundwater Monitoring & Remediation, 1982