Imaginative encounters: Turkish neo-Ottomanist dreams in the Balkans and the Muslim minorities
Open Access
- 17 February 2026
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Critical Research on Religion
Abstract
Turkey’s political, financial, and cultural investments in Southeastern Europe are often analyzed through “soft power” frameworks that read its neo-Ottomanist ambitions unidirectional and cast Balkan Muslims as passive recipients. Based on ethnographic fieldwork (2018–2022) with diverse Muslims in North Macedonia and Kosovo, this article challenges such accounts by showing how local actors actively engage with, reinterpret, and redirect Turkey’s imperial revival projects. Using takhayyul —a Non-Eurocentric formulation of imagination—as the theoretical framework, the analysis embraces the messiness of imaginative encounters across intersecting historical narratives and political aspirations. It traces how Balkan Muslim communities deploy sophisticated strategies of selective appropriation, maintain historical agency while navigating Turkey's diverse investments. Juxtaposing resurrection themes in Turkish Islamic revivalism with local pride narratives of Islamic primacy and resistance, the article demonstrates how imagination functions as political currency across post-Ottoman spaces, revealing the inadequacy of linear or hierarchical models of influence for understanding contemporary Islamist formations.Keywords
Funding Information
- H2020 European Research Council (853230)
This publication has 51 references indexed in Scilit:
- Monastic avoidance: piety and ambivalence in pre-2016 TurkeyContemporary Islam, 2025
- Politicizing Prophethood: Techniques of Far-Right Encroachment on Civil Society in PakistanInternational Journal of Politics, Culture, and Society, 2025
- Neo-Ottomanism, Islam and migrants: the AKP’s battle in North CyprusThird World Quarterly, 2025
- Islam, critique, and the canon: an introductionContemporary Islam, 2024
- “Traitor over a night”: on critique and the fragility of privilege in the aftermath of Turkey’s coup attemptContemporary Islam, 2023
- Reassessing Turkish National Memory: An Analysis of the Representation of Turkish National Memory by the AKPMiddle Eastern Studies, 2014
- “The Balkans’ Other within”: Imaginings of the West in the Republic of MacedoniaHistory and Anthropology, 2008
- The conceptualization of an Albanian nationEthnic and Racial Studies, 1997
- Albanian self‐understanding through non‐violence: The construction of national identity in opposition to SerbsJournal of Area Studies, 1993
- A Desire of One’s Own: Psychoanalytic Feminism and Intersubjective Space1986