Publishing FAIR and machine-actionable reviews in materials science: The case for symbolic knowledge in neuro-symbolic artificial intelligence
Open Access
- 16 April 2026
- journal article
- Published by American Vacuum Society in Journal of Vacuum Science & Technology A
- Vol. 44 (3)
Abstract
Scientific reviews are central to knowledge integration in materials science, yet their key insights remain locked in narrative text and static PDF tables, limiting reuse by humans and machines alike. This article presents a case study in atomic layer deposition and etching (ALD/E) where we publish review tables as FAIR, machine-actionable comparisons in the Open Research Knowledge Graph (ORKG), turning them into structured, queryable knowledge. Building on this, we contrast symbolic querying over ORKG with large language model-based querying and argue that a curated symbolic layer should remain the backbone of reliable neurosymbolic AI in materials science, with LLMs serving as complementary, symbolically grounded interfaces rather than standalone sources of truth.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 27 references indexed in Scilit:
- Atomic Layer Deposition on Particulate Materials from 1988 through 2023: A Quantitative Review of Technologies, Materials, and ApplicationsChemistry of Materials, 2025
- MOF-ChemUnity: Literature-Informed Large Language Models for Metal–Organic Framework ResearchJournal of the American Chemical Society, 2025
- Atomic and Molecular Layer Deposition of Functional Thin Films Based on Rare Earth ElementsAdvanced Materials Interfaces, 2024
- MatKG: An autonomously generated knowledge graph in Material ScienceScientific Data, 2024
- Mechanisms of Thermal Atomic Layer EtchingAccounts of Chemical Research, 2020
- Thermal atomic layer etching: Mechanism, materials and prospectsProgress in Natural Science: Materials International, 2018
- Atomic Layer Etching: Rethinking the Art of EtchThe Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters, 2018
- Atomic Layer Deposition: An OverviewChemical Reviews, 2009
- Atomic layer deposition (ALD): from precursors to thin film structuresThin Solid Films, 2002
- Atomic layer epitaxyMaterials Science Reports, 1989