Productive explanation: A framework for evaluating explanations in psychological science.
Top Cited Papers
Open Access
- 1 March 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Psychological Review
- Vol. 132 (2) , 311-329
Abstract
The explanation of psychological phenomena is a central aim of psychological science. However, the nature of explanation and the processes by which we evaluate whether a theory explains a phenomenon are often unclear. Consequently, it is often unknown whether a given psychological theory indeed explains a phenomenon. We address this shortcoming by proposing a productive account of explanation: a theory explains a phenomenon to some degree if and only if a formal model of the theory produces the statistical pattern representing the phenomenon. Using this account, we outline a workable methodology of explanation: (a) explicating a verbal theory into a formal model, (b) representing phenomena as statistical patterns in data, and (c) assessing whether the formal model produces these statistical patterns. In addition, we provide three major criteria for evaluating the goodness of an explanation (precision, robustness, and empirical relevance), and examine some cases of explanatory breakdowns. Finally, we situate our framework within existing theories of explanation from philosophy of science and discuss how our approach contributes to constructing and developing better psychological theories. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2024 APA, all rights reserved).Keywords
All Related Versions
Funding Information
- Dutch Research Council (181.029)
- National Institute of Mental Health (K23 MH113805)
- Dutch Ministry of Education, Culture and Science (024.004.016)
This publication has 39 references indexed in Scilit:
- Why most psychological research findings are not even wrongInfant and Child Development, 2022
- Code Sharing in the Open Science EraJournal of Chemical Information and Modeling, 2020
- How to Translate a Verbal Theory Into a Formal ModelSocial Psychology, 2020
- Digital Footprints of Sensation SeekingZeitschrift für Psychologie, 2018
- Estimating the parameters of system dynamics models using indirect inferenceSystem Dynamics Review, 2016
- Insight Maker: A general-purpose tool for web-based modeling & simulationSimulation Modelling Practice and Theory, 2014
- Why self-control seems (but may not be) limitedTrends in Cognitive Sciences, 2014
- Registered Reports: A new publishing initiative at CortexCortex, 2013
- Inference to the best explanation, coherence and other explanatory virtuesSynthese, 2011
- Dissecting explanatory powerPhilosophical Studies, 2008