Abstract
REVIEWS 177 Richard N. Coe, When the Grass was Taller: Autobiography and the Experience of Childhood. New Haven and London: Yale University Press, 1984. 352 pp. $27.50. This already widely-touted study of "the experience of Childhood" is amply deserving of the kudos it has received. Demonstrating a vast and intimate knowledge of this fascinating subject, the author has once and for all laid to rest those sentimental appreciations of the experience which seemed to proliferate, largely in an Anglo-Saxon context , from roughly 1880 to the present. To do this, he has broadened his vision to include texts from world literature, not least telling of which are those from Russia and those written in English from the Indian subcontinent. The reading required for this foray—and it provides much more than an overview—is simply prodigious, holding the reader in awe. There is no bibliography, however, yet is the author's explanation of its lack by reference to one of his own ancillary publications on pages 82 and 297 sufficient to remedy the situation? (I recognize the problem—a complete bibliography would indeed have increased the size of the volume unduly—but not quite how it could be handled otherwise. Caveat lector.) Another innovation is the refusal to belabor the Augustine-Rousseau connection as central to any discussion of the autobiography of Childhood. Yet, despite some excellent pages on the latter's Confessions (notably on pages 30-6 and 72-6), has everything been said about the connection, as Georges May wondered in his study of the genre? Is it superfluous to dwell, for example , on the confessional mode or form as it applies to Childhood? The answer given here is that, rather than the autobiography itself, it is the mythology of Childhood which looms most important. To deal adequately with this problematic, the author proceeds in an innovative— and convincing—way by beginning his study with the experience of Childhood and its development from a real or imagined age of innocence (chapter 1), passing in the next chapter to the intellectual transformations of truthfulness, memory, and artifice, before arriving in chapter 3 at what appears to be the core of the argument or thesis. There, in dealing with myth proper, the author interprets pro and con the magic generated by childhood. Chapters 4 and 5 deal with the attributes of authorship determining the nature of the presentation and our reaction, while chapter 6 examines the world of the child on a selective basis that more than adequately serves to provide a reified, social, or other frame of reference, without the repetitions such a procedure frequently entails. Finally in chapter 7 are broached those questions of theory which in the hands of a less astute critic would have come first, possibly dulling the reader's interest or the writer's focus. While this seemingly awkward positioning might otherwise tend to vitiate the generation of a convincing argument, the author's apposite defense is nicely expressed on page xiii. The overall result is, therefore, as previous reviewers have been quick to note approvingly, a marvellous display of the taxonomy of the experience of Childhood that naturally invites further reflection and delight, one that is unique of its kind. There are two points which might bear further scrutiny. Whether the questions they pose are answerable is moot, but they might have helped clarify, illumine or illustrate part of the author's argument for this reviewer. The first relates to the definition of the genre on pages 8-9: an extended piece of writing, a conscious, deliberately executed artifact, usually in prose (and thus intimately related to the novel) but not excluding occasional experiments in verse, in which the most substantial portion of the material is 178 biography Vol. 10,No. 2 directly autobiographical, and whose structure reflects, step by step the development of the writer's self; beginning often, but not invariably, with the first light of consciousness, and concluding, quite specifically, with the attainment of a precise degree of maturity. While it is possible to go along with the general tenor of this premise, I cannot help wondering if it does not open the floodgates to confusion. For, as...