Why Broadgate Phase 8 composite floor did not fail under fire
Author:
- 27 July 2017
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Journal of Structural Fire Engineering
- Vol. 8 (3) , 238-257
Abstract
Purpose: This paper aims to present the findings of a numerical investigation into the performance of the steel-concrete composite floor involved in Broadgate Phase 8 fire. Design/methodology/approach: The investigation is conducted by carrying out a 3-D thermomechanical analysis of a composite floor similar to the one involved in the fire using ANSYS. Four fire scenarios are investigated, with each producing a unique stress – strain pattern. The results obtained are compared with the observations made after the fire and inferences drawn. Findings: The results obtained are found to be correlated with the observations made after the fire. The performance of the composite floor is found to be dominated by development of large strains, leading to large deflections. Furthermore, colder parts of the structure, through redistribution of forces, are found to have a profound impact on the ability of a composite floor to resist heating effects. From the findings, it is concluded that connections’ design, occurrence of membrane action and thermal restraints were the key reasons the floor did not fail. Originality value: The study takes a more forensic approach. This is a departure from majority of published literature, where comparison is usually between experimental and numerical results. By comparing the findings from a real fire with those of a numerical investigation, the study provides an insight into the accuracy of applying numerical models for the prediction of effects of fire on structural behaviour.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Influence of Tensile Membrane Action on Fire-exposed Composite Concrete Floor-steel Beams with Web-openingsProcedia Engineering, 2013
- A Study of Thermal Behavior of a Composite Floor System in Standard Fire Resistance Tests2012
- Recent Lessons Learned in Structural Fire Engineering for Composite Steel StructuresFire Technology, 2012
- The World Trade Center 9/11 Disaster and Progressive Collapse of Tall BuildingsFire Technology, 2012
- Nonlinear dynamic simulations of progressive collapse for a multistory buildingEngineering Structures, 2010
- Modelling of the Cardington LBTF steel frame building fire testsFire and Materials, 2004
- How did the WTC towers collapse: a new theoryFire Safety Journal, 2003
- Modelling of heated composite floor slabs with reference to the Cardington experimentsFire Safety Journal, 2001
- Predicting the Temperatures of Steel Members in the Cardington Fire Tests Using the THELMA Finite Element ModelFire Technology, 2001
- Lateral-Distortional buckling of steel I—Section membersJournal of Constructional Steel Research, 1992