Comparative Analysis of Test Methods for Predicting Dermal Sensitization Potency in Essential Oils: A Component-Based Prediction Model, GARDskin Dose-Response Assay, and Local Lymph Node Assay
Preprint
- 7 July 2026
- preprint
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Abstract
The GARDskin DR assay is a non-animal method that predicts dermal sensitization potency of discrete compounds. This comparative analysis evaluates outputs from a component-based prediction model (CP), GARDskin DR, and historical local lymph node assays (LLNA) exploring the applicability of CP and GARDskin DR for evaluating the sensitization potencies of essential oils. Eight well-studied essential oils were selected including cedarwood, cinnamon bark, clove bud, geranium, lavender, lemongrass, spearmint, and tea tree oils. Each underwent GC-MS and GARDskin DR analysis. CP model outputs, GARDskin DR and reference LLNA data were compared using standard statistical methods. Spearman’s test shows significant correlation between NESILCP vs. NESILGARD (0.881, p = 0.007) and NESILLLNA (0.929, p = 0.007) but not between NESILGARD vs. NESILLLNA (0.607, p = 0.17). Friedman’s test detected a significant difference among methods (χ²(2) = 7.71, p = 0.021), with post hoc tests showing relatively greater NESILCP values. Kendall’s W shows overall strong statistical concordance between methods (0.857, p = 0.017). NESILGARD and NESILCP generally align with NESILLLNA for the essential oils tested, although the CP method yields greater values. With the limited number of materials tested, results should be interpreted descriptively but show promise for GARDskin DR and CP for evaluating dermal sensitization potency of essential oils.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 53 references indexed in Scilit:
- The skin allergy risk assessment-integrated chemical environment (SARA-ICE) defined approach to derive points of departure for skin sensitizationCurrent Research in Toxicology, 2024
- RIFM fragrance ingredient safety assessment, p-mentha-1,3-diene, CAS Registry Number 99-86-5Food and Chemical Toxicology, 2022
- RIFM fragrance ingredient safety assessment, citronellyl formate, CAS Registry number 105-85-1Food and Chemical Toxicology, 2021
- RIFM fragrance ingredient safety assessment, benzyl benzoate, CAS Registry Number 120-51-4Food and Chemical Toxicology, 2020
- RIFM fragrance ingredient safety assessment, cinnamaldehyde, CAS Registry Number 104-55-2Food and Chemical Toxicology, 2019
- Criteria for the Research Institute for Fragrance Materials, Inc. (RIFM) safety evaluation process for fragrance ingredientsFood and Chemical Toxicology, 2015
- Essential Oil Safety2014
- Investigation of the dermal sensitization potential of various essential oils in the local lymph node assayFood and Chemical Toxicology, 2006
- An α, β-unsaturated oxime identified as a strong contact allergenFood and Chemical Toxicology, 2005
- Assessment of the skin sensitization potency of eugenol and its dimers using a non‐radioisotopic modification of the local lymph node assayJournal of Applied Toxicology, 2004