Reliability analysis and uncertainty quantification of clay and sand slopes stability evaluated by Fellenius and Bishop’s simplified methods
Author:
Open Access
- 11 November 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in International Journal of Geo-Engineering
- Vol. 14 (1) , 1-15
Abstract
Slope stabilities are mainly designed using the conventional design approach (CDA), where the limit equilibrium methods (LEMs) are performed. Fellenius and Bishop’s simplified methods are the two commonly LEMs adopted as recommended in most design codes. In the design process of CDA, the safety factors (FS) of slopes are checked with specified FSs to ensure stability. The CDA has inherent drawbacks because the design process does not account for uncertainties. Moreover, different LEMs using different assumptions to solve the safety factors might include some amount orders of approximations. This study conducts probabilistic analyses, i.e., Monte Carlo simulations (MCSs) and uncertainty quantification, to obtain insights into the two LEMs applied to clay and sand slopes. The results reveal that the reliability indexes (RIs) obtained from the two LEMs-based MCSs are relatively identical for the same slope. Concerning the soil types, however, the RIs of the clay slope are significantly lower than those estimated for the sand slope, regardless of the LEMs used. The uncertainty quantifications for the clay slopes reveal that the two LEMs have relatively similar bias factors regarding FSs. Nevertheless, using the Fellenius method underestimates the probabilistic safety (about 17% in terms of the mean of FSs) for the sand slope compared to Bishop’s simplified method. Moreover, the coefficients of variation of FS obtained from the clay slope are consistently larger than those from the sand slope. These observations imply that the clay slope is more uncertain than the sand slope, and the Fellenius method results in lower FSs for sand slopes. Therefore, the FSs specified in the design codes should be connected to the soil type or the LEMs used to achieve the same probabilistic safety levels. Finally, the equivalent FSs associated with a RI of 1.75 are derived for each slope and each LEM used.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- Probabilistic analysis of the active earth pressure on earth retaining walls for c-ϕ soils according to the Mazindrani and Ganjali methodInternational Journal of Geo-Engineering, 2021
- Calibration of Load and Resistance Factors for Breakwater Foundations under the Earthquake LoadingSustainability, 2021
- Seismic analysis of slope considering log-spiral failure surface with numerical validationInternational Journal of Geo-Engineering, 2020
- Probabilistic Risk Evaluation for Overall Stability of Composite Caisson Breakwaters in KoreaJournal of Marine Science and Engineering, 2020
- Comparison of Point Estimate and Monte Carlo probabilistic methods in stability analysis of a deep excavationInternational Journal of Geo-Engineering, 2018
- Risk and Reliability in Geotechnical Engineering2018
- System probabilistic stability analysis of soil slopes using Gaussian process regression with Latin hypercube samplingComputers and Geotechnics, 2015
- Stratified Response Surfaces for System Probabilistic Evaluation of SlopesJournal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering, 2012
- Efficient Evaluation of Reliability for Slopes with Circular Slip Surfaces Using Importance SamplingJournal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering, 2009
- Calibration methods for reliability-based design codesStructural Safety, 2004