SOFTWARE COMPONENT DEVELOPMENT FOR PARALLEL GATEWAYS DETECTION AND QUALITY ASSESSMENT IN BPMN MODELS USING FUZZY LOGIC
Open Access
- 11 July 2025
- journal article
- Published by National Technical University Kharkiv Polytechnic Institute in Bulletin of National Technical University "KhPI". Series: System Analysis, Control and Information Technologies
- No. 1 (13),p. 117-124
Abstract
The quality of business process models is a critical factor in ensuring the correctness, efficiency, and maintainability of information systems. Within the BPMN notation, which is nowadays a standard of business processes modeling, parallel (AND) gateways are of particular importance. Errors in their implementation, such as incorrect synchronization or termination of parallel branches, are common and difficult to detect by traditional metrics such as the Number of Activities (NOA) or Control-Flow Complexity (CFC). In this paper, we propose a method for evaluating the correctness of AND-gateways based on fuzzy logic using Gaussian membership functions. The proposed approach is implemented as a software component that analyzes BPMN models, provided in XML format, identifies all AND-gateways, and extracts structural characteristics, i.e. the numbers of incoming and outgoing sequence flows. This features are evaluated using “soft” modeling rules based on fuzzy membership functions. Additionally, an activation function with the 0.5 threshold is used to generate binary quality indicators and calculate an integral quality assessment measure. The software component is developed using Python, as well as third-party libraries: Pandas, NumPy, and Matplotlib. A set of 3729 BPMN models from the Camunda open source repository was used for experimental calculations. Of these, 1355 models contain 3171 AND-gateways. The obtained results demonstrate that 71.2% of the gateways are correct, and 28.8% have structural violations. In 50% of the models, the quality score is 1.00, which indicates high quality, however minimum values of 0.02 indicate the need for automated verification of business process models. The considered approach allows detecting AND-gateways modeling errors, increasing the reliability of BPMN models and offering the capabilities for intelligent business process modeling support.Keywords
This publication has 12 references indexed in Scilit:
- Business Process Models and Eye Tracking System for BPMN Evaluation-Usability Study2023
- Comparative analysis of selected process maturity assessment models applied in the public sectorBusiness Process Management Journal, 2023
- The biggest business process management problems to solve before we dieComputers in Industry, 2023
- Multi-attribute Transformers for Sequence Prediction in Business Process Management2022
- Probabilistic Model Checking of BPMN Processes at Runtime2022
- Consistent modelling of hierarchical BPMN collaborationsBusiness Process Management Journal, 2022
- Business Process Design2022
- Business Process Management: The evolution of a disciplineComputers in Industry, 2021
- Enterprise modelling: Research review and outlookComputers in Industry, 2020
- Complexity Clustering of BPMN Models: Initial Experiments with the K-means Algorithm2020