Energy-Aware Benchmarking of Quantum Machine Learning for Financial Prediction Tasks: An Accuracy–Sustainability Pareto Analysis of Hybrid Quantum–Classical Pipelines
Preprint
- 21 October 2026
- preprint
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Abstract
Quantum machine learning (QML) is increasingly proposed for financial forecasting and risk analysis, yet comparisons with classical methods almost always stop at accuracy and wall-clock time. As quantum systems approach deployment, their resource footprint — cryogenic cooling, repeated circuit executions, calibration and the classical optimiser loops surrounding them — becomes a first-order concern. This paper introduces an energy-aware benchmarking framework for hybrid quantum–classical ML pipelines and applies it to three financial tasks: credit-risk scoring (UCI German Credit) and next-day direction prediction for the S&P 500 and NIFTY 50 indices. Variational quantum classifiers (VQC) and quantum-kernel support vector machines (QSVM) at 4–8 qubits are compared with class-weighted logistic regression, RBF-SVM, random forest, XGBoost and a GPU-trained LSTM on identical data subsets. Classical energy is measured directly by a 10 Hz power sampler; quantum energy combines the measured optimisation-loop energy with a per-shot hardware cost model spanning optimistic to pessimistic scenarios. On credit risk the best quantum model (QSVM, 8 qubits) trails logistic regression by 7.8 balanced-accuracy points while consuming 7 × 1010 times its energy. On index direction all models, classical and quantum, perform at chance, so the 109× quantum energy premium purchases nothing. The gap is insensitive to the hardware assumption: break-even would require roughly 10-10 J per shot, ten orders of magnitude below current superconducting systems. Once the statistical uncertainty of the accuracy estimates is taken into account, no quantum model.Keywords
This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit:
- Carbon efficient quantum AI: an empirical study of ansätz design trade-offs in QNN and QLSTM modelsScientific Reports, 2025
- Quantum computing for financeNature Reviews Physics, 2023
- Is quantum computing green? An estimate for an energy-efficiency quantum advantageQuantum Science and Technology, 2023
- Variational quantum algorithmsNature Reviews Physics, 2021
- A rigorous and robust quantum speed-up in supervised machine learningNature Physics, 2021
- Circuit-centric quantum classifiersPhysical Review A, 2020
- Quantum computing for finance: Overview and prospectsReviews in Physics, 2019
- Evaluating analytic gradients on quantum hardwarePhysical Review A, 2019
- Supervised learning with quantum-enhanced feature spacesNature, 2019
- Quantum Machine Learning in Feature Hilbert SpacesPhysical Review Letters, 2019