Statistical considerations in the analysis of minirhizotron data and a review of current practice in agronomic research
Open Access
- 7 January 2025
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Wiley in Vadose Zone Journal
- Vol. 24 (1)
Abstract
A growing body of agronomic research seeks to understand the drivers of plant‐ and field‐scale patterns of crop root system distribution, and how root system distribution in turn affects crop performance. Minirhizotrons play an important role in this effort due to the unique opportunities they provide for collecting in situ root measurements, nondestructively, under field conditions, over a deep (albeit narrow) section of the soil profile. Alongside these advantages and opportunities, however, minirhizotron data also feature a number of idiosyncrasies with potentially important implications for their analysis, including (i) doubly repeated measures in time and space, (ii) non‐normal data with a potentially large number of zeros, and (iii) data subjected to spatial aggregation and, thus, the modifiable areal unit problem. Twenty years of peer‐reviewed journal articles from field trials using minirhizotrons to study cultivated species were reviewed to understand how these statistical issues are being addressed in contemporary agronomic research. The findings indicate that a large proportion of analyses make no effort to account for these issues; it is possible the authors are not aware of them or their implications. Furthermore, even where the analytical methods do reflect concern about one or more of these issues, many studies remain reliant on antiquated and potentially inefficient methods. Crop root systems researchers need to familiarize themselves with more modern, flexible approaches to statistical analysis appropriate to their data and their research objectives, while journals and reviewers need to redouble their efforts to enforce statistical rigor in the works they publish.Keywords
This publication has 47 references indexed in Scilit:
- Analyze as randomized—Why dropping block effects in designed experiments is a bad ideaAgronomy Journal, 2024
- Writing statistical methods for ecologistsEcosphere, 2023
- Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions2019
- Assumptions in Nonparametric Tests2019
- The mismatch between current statistical practice and doctoral training in ecologyEcosphere, 2016
- Reproducible research in statistics: A review and guidelines for the Biometrical JournalBiometrical Journal, 2015
- Spatial and Spatio‐Temporal Geostatistical Modeling and Kriging2015
- Statistical Design2008
- Linear Mixed Models for Longitudinal Data2000
- Logarithmic transformation bias in allometryAmerican Journal of Physical Anthropology, 1993