The role of ulterior motives, inconsistencies, and details in unreliable jailhouse informant testimony
- 3 January 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Psychology, Crime & Law
- Vol. 26 (7) , 667-686
Abstract
The present study explored whether the successful detection of a jailhouse informant's ulterior motives, inconsistencies in testimony, and knowledge of privileged crime details would influence verdict decisions. Undergraduate participants (N = 381, 218 females) listened to a trial transcript in which a jailhouse informant's testimony was manipulated such that (1) the ulterior motive to provide false testimony was made salient or not, (2) an inconsistency was pointed out between the informant's testimony and a prior statement or not, and (3) an alternative explanation for how the informant learned the privileged crime details was suggested or not. Results showed both inconsistency and alternative explanation reduced conviction rates, though this was mediated by motive attributions. Participants appeared to interpret evidence differently depending on their motive attribution of the jailhouse informant. Participants who attributed the informant's behaviors to situational factors (i.e. reduced sentence) were more likely to vote not guilty and were more persuaded by the inconsistency and alternative explanation than participants who made dispositional attributions (i.e. he felt bad for the family, it's the right thing to do).Keywords
This publication has 25 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Jury Under Fire2017
- Mock juror sampling issues in jury simulation research: A meta-analysis.Law and Human Behavior, 2017
- Overlooking the Obvious: Incentives to LieBasic and Applied Social Psychology, 2013
- Convicting the Innocent2011
- Can the Jury Disregard that Information? The Use of Suspicion to Reduce the Prejudicial Effects of Pretrial Publicity and Inadmissible TestimonyPersonality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 1997
- Effects of suspicion on attributional thinking and the correspondence bias.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1996
- Effects of inconsistencies in eyewitness testimony on mock-juror decision making.Journal of Applied Psychology, 1996
- Effects of inconsistent eyewitness statements on mock-jurors' evaluations of the eyewitness, perceptions of defendant culpability and verdicts.Law and Human Behavior, 1995
- Suspicion of ulterior motivation and the correspondence bias.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1990
- The moderator–mediator variable distinction in social psychological research: Conceptual, strategic, and statistical considerations.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1986