Computerized Analysis of Crustacean Relationships

Author:

Abstract
The strengths and weaknesses of phylogenetic analysis using computers are reviewed from the viewpoint of understanding crustacean evolution. Computerized methods require the explicit presentation of characters and character state homologies. New techniques allow investigators to design evolutionary models into a character data matrix, or to use evolutionary models that make minimal a priori assumptions. The computer analysis relieves the investigator from the highly repetitious testing of trees, allows the concentration on the character state data, and provides objective methods for comparing trees, primarily their length. These are regarded as the strengths of computerized methods. The weaknesses of these methods include the relatively inscrutable nature of the character data matrix compared with the overall ‘gestalt’ of resulting trees, the difficulties of defining discrete homologies within the Crustacea, especially for counts of segmentation, the lack of clear intermediate character states in some multistate segmental characters, and the inability to define evolutionary polarity. These difficulties may be overcome by analysing the data using the minimal assumption models of character evolution, and by a recognition that the trees are a result of the input data, and therefore the data should be criticized, rather than the trees themselves. A ‘consensus’ character data set, including most extant major groups of the Crustacea as well as several key fossils, was assembled and revised by the participants in the workshop. An artificial taxon, ‘ur‐crustacean characters’, was introduced to root the tree. Three observations may be made from parsimony analyses using several weighting and tree rooting methods. (1) The currently accepted large scale phylogeny and classification of the Crustacea is not corroborated. (2) The number of supposed plesiomorphic traits possessed by a taxon is not a good index for early derivation in crustacean evolution. (3) The taxon Maxillopoda is not supported by the arrangement of any of the trees.

This publication has 12 references indexed in Scilit: