Abstract
On June 7, President Donald Trump issued a memorandum federalizing 2,000 California National Guard troops to quell immigration protests in and around Los Angeles pursuant to an obscure provision in federal law–10 USC §12406–which has not been used since 1970, when President Richard Nixon federalized the Guard to deliver mail during a postal strike. And the last time the National Guard was federalized over a governor’s objection was in 1965, when President Lyndon B. Johnson deployed the Guard to Selma, Alabama to protect civil rights demonstrators. The law allows federalization of National Guard forces if “there is a rebellion or danger of a rebellion against the authority of the Government of the United States.” Although the deployed military force may protect federal officers enforcing immigration law in Los Angeles, the federalized Guard is, like any federal military force, subject to the Posse Comitatus Act, which prohibits federal troops from being directly involved in domestic law enforcement. In Los Angeles, that means Guard troops are unable to conduct immigration raids, detain persons or make arrests, or in any way engage in direct law enforcement.Trump’s actions in Los Angeles are part of a larger effort to militarize immigration enforcement. He has another, lesser-known, tool at his disposal that he can use to dramatically increase the number of Guard troops involved in these types of activities. Known as the 287(g) program, it delegates immigration enforcement to state and local law enforcement agencies. We worry that using 287 (g) agreements to enable National Guard units to enforce immigration laws creates enormous risk, undermines military readiness, and threatens the longstanding traditions of separating military functions from civil society. As one of us has written before, domestic use of the military is often fraught and is just as often corrosive to American democracy. Part-time soldiers police their neighbors, federal authority needlessly displaces state and local elected officials, and the relationship between the military and civil society becomes strained.