The paradox of primitivism: Native rights and the problem of imagery in cultural survival films
Author:
- 1 February 1997
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Visual Anthropology
- Vol. 9 (3-4) , 243-266
Abstract
Indigenous peoples are increasingly interested in the making of cultural survival films. This text explores the cinematic borderland where indigenous communities, action anthropologists, and committed filmmakers jointly operate in the production of such native rights documentaries. Considering the role of exotic imagery as an ideological force in the international political arena, the paper identifies and explores the paradox of primitivism. Comparing films to tribal masks, it discusses how indigenous peoples deal with the challenge and opportunity of such imagery. Offering examples of two tribal film projects, with Mi'kmaqs and Apaches, it concludes that exotic imagery, while effective (perhaps even essential) as political agency, may pervert the cultural heritage that indigenous peoples are committed to preserving.Keywords
This publication has 3 references indexed in Scilit:
- Echoing images: The construction of savagery among Papua new Guinean villagersVisual Anthropology, 1992
- Abnaki: The Native People of Maine. 1982. A film by Jay Kent and the Tribal Governors, Inc.: Our Sacred Land. 1984. Produced by Chris Spotted Eagle.: Incident at Restigouche. 1984. A film by Alanis Obomsawin.: Nations Within a Nation: Sovereignty and Native American Communities. 1986. Produced by Donald N. Brown and Mark Ringwald.: Home of the Brave. 1985. A film by Helena Solberg‐Ladd.: Contrary Warriors—A Film of the Crow Tribe. 1986. A film by Connie Poten, Pamela Roberts, and Beth Ferris.American Anthropologist, 1988
- Film ReviewAmerican Anthropologist, 1988