Factors influencing utilisation of ‘free-standing’ and ‘alongside’ midwifery units for low-risk births in England: a mixed-methods study
Authors:
- Denis WalshDWDenis Walsh
- Helen SpibyHSHelen Spiby
- Christine McCourtCMChristine McCourt
- Dawn ColebyDCDawn Coleby
- Celia GriggCGCelia Grigg
- Simon BishopSBSimon Bishop
- Miranda ScanlonMSMiranda Scanlon
- Lorraine CulleyLCLorraine Culley
- Jane WilkinsonJWJane Wilkinson
- Lynne PacanowskiLPLynne Pacanowski
- Jim ThorntonJTJim Thornton
- 1 February 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in Health Services and Delivery Research
- Vol. 8 (12) , 1-106
Abstract
Background: Midwifery-led units (MUs) are recommended for ‘low-risk’ births by the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence but according to the National Audit Office were not available in one-quarter of trusts in England in 2013 and, when available, were used by only a minority of the low-risk women for whom they should be suitable. This study explores why.Objectives: To map the provision of MUs in England and explore barriers to and facilitators of their development and use; and to ascertain stakeholder views of interventions to address these barriers and facilitators.Design: Mixed methods – first, MU access and utilisation across England was mapped; second, local media coverage of the closure of free-standing midwifery units (FMUs) were analysed; third, case studies were undertaken in six sites to explore the barriers and facilitators that have an impact on the development of MUs; and, fourth, by convening a stakeholder workshop, interventions to address the barriers and facilitators were discussed.Setting: English NHS maternity services.Participants: All trusts with maternity services.Interventions: Establishing MUs.Main outcome measures: Numbers and types of MUs and utilisation of MUs.Results: Births in MUs across England have nearly tripled since 2011, to 15% of all births. However, this increase has occurred almost exclusively in alongside units, numbers of which have doubled. Births in FMUs have stayed the same and these units are more susceptible to closure. One-quarter of trusts in England have no MUs; in those that do, nearly all MUs are underutilised. The study findings indicate that most trust managers, senior midwifery managers and obstetricians do not regard their MU provision as being as important as their obstetric-led unit provision and therefore it does not get embedded as an equal and parallel component in the trust’s overall maternity package of care. The analysis illuminates how provision and utilisation are influenced by a complex range of factors, including the medicalisation of childbirth, financial constraints and institutional norms protecting the status quo.Limitations: When undertaking the case studies, we were unable to achieve representativeness across social class in the women’s focus groups and struggled to recruit finance directors for individual interviews. This may affect the transferability of our findings.Conclusions: Although there has been an increase in the numbers and utilisation of MUs since 2011, significant obstacles remain to MUs reaching their full potential, especially FMUs. This includes the capacity and willingness of providers to address women’s information needs. If these remain unaddressed at commissioner and provider level, childbearing women’s access to MUs will continue to be restricted.Future work: Work is needed on optimum approaches to improve decision-makers’ understanding and use of clinical and economic evidence in service design. Increasing women’s access to information about MUs requires further studies of professionals’ understanding and communication of evidence. The role of FMUs in the context of rural populations needs further evaluation to take into account user and community impact.Funding: This project was funded by the National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) Health Services and Delivery Research programme and will be published in full inHealth Services and Delivery Research; Vol. 8, No. 12. See the NIHR Journals Library website for further project information.Keywords
Funding Information
- Health Services and Delivery Research (HS&DR) Programme (14/04/28)
This publication has 127 references indexed in Scilit:
- Duration and urgency of transfer in births planned at home and in freestanding midwifery units in England: secondary analysis of the Birthplace national prospective cohort studyBMC Pregnancy and Childbirth, 2013
- Evaluation of a large-scale weight management program using the consolidated framework for implementation research (CFIR)Implementation Science, 2013
- Women’s experience of transfer from midwifery unit to hospital obstetric unit during labour: a qualitative interview studyBMC Pregnancy and Childbirth, 2012
- Perinatal and maternal outcomes by planned place of birth for healthy women with low risk pregnancies: the Birthplace in England national prospective cohort studyBMJ, 2011
- Freestanding midwifery unit versus obstetric unit: a matched cohort study of outcomes in low-risk womenBMJ Open, 2011
- Is the operative delivery rate in low-risk women dependent on the level of birth care? A randomised controlled trialBJOG: An International Journal of Obstetrics & Gynaecology, 2011
- Developing the tools of implementation science in substance use disorders treatment: Applications of the consolidated framework for implementation research.Psychology of Addictive Behaviors, 2011
- Fostering implementation of health services research findings into practice: a consolidated framework for advancing implementation scienceImplementation Science, 2009
- Births in two different delivery units in the same clinic – A prospective study of healthy primiparous womenBMC Pregnancy and Childbirth, 2009
- The market in primary careBMJ, 2007