‘Empty Nets’
- 26 August 2009
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Party Politics
- Vol. 15 (5) , 635-653
Abstract
The Social Democratic parties of Germany and Sweden were part of ‘third way’ movements common to such political parties during the mid-1990s. By continuing to moderate their positions and move away from their traditional bases towards the centre, they seemed to embody — a generation later — a second embracing of Kirchheimer’s ‘catch-all’ party thesis. But unlike its 1960s’ incarnation, each of them in the mid-1990s disregarded their left flanks and saw considerable growth of both Green and Left (former communist) parties fill the policy space that social democracy had relinquished. Both parties no longer lead their governments. This article suggests that the decline of social democracy in Germany and Sweden can be understood by a nuanced interpretation of the Kirchheimer thesis. Ultimately, it is argued that the failure of both parties to maintain electoral dominance results, paradoxically, from their overemphasis on the political centre, which left a lucrative space for left-wing parties to occupy especially in a PR setting. Kirchheimer helps us understand this pattern, because the focus on the centre leaves an ideologically moribund electorate that created space for Left parties to institutionally renew or adapt themselves to address the needs of these forgotten voters. This central hypothesis, along with others that derive from the catch-all thesis, is tested empirically with historical analysis and electoral and opinion data.Keywords
This publication has 29 references indexed in Scilit:
- Towards a two-party system? The Swedish parliamentary election of September 2006West European Politics, 2007
- Do Policy Horizons Structure the Formation of Parliamentary Governments?: The Evidence from an Expert SurveyAmerican Journal of Political Science, 2005
- Does winning pay? Electoral success and government formation in 15 West European countriesEuropean Journal of Political Research, 2004
- Agenda 2010: Redefining German Social DemocracyGerman Politics and Society, 2004
- The SPD, the Welfare State, and Agenda 2010German Politics and Society, 2003
- Scandinavia: What's Left is the Social Democratic Welfare ConsensusParliamentary Affairs, 2003
- Coping with Permanent Austerity: Welfare State Restructuring in Affluent DemocraciesRevue Française de Sociologie, 2002
- Continuity or Politikwechsel? The First Federal Red-Green CoalitionGerman Politics and Society, 2002
- Party Membership in Twenty European Democracies, 1980-2000Party Politics, 2001
- Back to the FutureParty Politics, 1995