Environmental efficiency of alternative dairy systems: A productive efficiency approach
- 1 November 2013
- journal article
- Published by American Dairy Science Association in Journal of Dairy Science
- Vol. 96 (11) , 7014-7031
Abstract
Agriculture across the globe needs to produce "more with less." Productivity should be increased in a sustainable manner so that the environment is not further degraded, management practices are both socially acceptable and economically favorable, and future generations are not disadvantaged. The objective of this paper was to compare the environmental efficiency of 2 divergent strains of Holstein-Friesian cows across 2 contrasting dairy management systems (grazing and nongrazing) over multiple years and so expose any genetic × environment (G × E) interaction. The models were an extension of the traditional efficiency analysis to account for undesirable outputs (pollutants), and estimate efficiency measures that allow for the asymmetric treatment of desirable outputs (i.e., milk production) and undesirable outputs. Two types of models were estimated, one considering production inputs (land, nitrogen fertilizers, feed, and cows) and the other not, thus allowing the assessment of the effect of inputs by comparing efficiency values and rankings between models. Each model type had 2 versions, one including 2 types of pollutants (greenhouse gas emissions, nitrogen surplus) and the other 3 (greenhouse gas emissions, nitrogen surplus, and phosphorus surplus). Significant differences were found between efficiency scores among the systems. Results indicated no G × E interaction; however, even though the select genetic merit herd consuming a diet with a higher proportion of concentrated feeds was most efficient in the majority of models, cows of the same genetic merit on higher forage diets could be just as efficient. Efficiency scores for the low forage groups were less variable from year to year, which reflected the uniformity of purchased concentrate feeds. The results also indicate that inputs play an important role in the measurement of environmental efficiency of dairy systems and that animal health variables (incidence of udder health disorders and body condition score) have a significant effect on the environmental efficiency of each dairy system. We conclude that traditional narrow measures of performance may not always distinguish dairy farming systems best fitted to future requirements.Keywords
This publication has 38 references indexed in Scilit:
- Effect of genotype and feeding regime on enteric methane, non-milk nitrogen and performance of dairy cows during the winter feeding periodLivestock Science, 2009
- Data Envelopment Analysis of different climate policy scenariosEcological Economics, 2008
- Dynamic environmental performance analysis: A Malmquist index approachEcological Economics, 2008
- Are larger farms more efficient?A farm level study of the relationships between efficiency and size on specialized dairy farms in SwedenAgricultural and Food Science, 2008
- Productivity growth and convergence in crop, ruminant, and nonruminant production: measurement and forecastsAgricultural Economics, 2007
- Productivity and grain or seed composition: a new approach to an old problem—invited paperEuropean Journal of Agronomy, 2002
- Assessment and Improvement of the Efficiency of Nitrogen Use in Clover Based and Fertilizer Based Dairy Systems. 1. Benchmarking using Farm Gate BalancesBiological Agriculture & Horticulture, 2002
- Agriculture's environmental externalities: DEA evidence for French agricultureApplied Economics, 1997
- An activity analysis model of the environmental performance of firms—application to fossil-fuel-fired electric utilitiesEcological Economics, 1996
- A new approach to photochemical pollution control: implications of spatial patterns in pollutant responses to reductions in nitrogen oxides and reactive organic gas emissionsEnvironmental Science & Technology, 1989