Competition, Alignment, and Equilibria in Digital Marketplaces
Preprint
Abstract
Competition between traditional platforms is known to improve user utility by aligning the platform's actions with user preferences. But to what extent is alignment exhibited in data-driven marketplaces? To study this question from a theoretical perspective, we introduce a duopoly market where platform actions are bandit algorithms and the two platforms compete for user participation. A salient feature of this market is that the quality of recommendations depends on both the bandit algorithm and the amount of data provided by interactions from users. This interdependency between the algorithm performance and the actions of users complicates the structure of market equilibria and their quality in terms of user utility. Our main finding is that competition in this market does not perfectly align market outcomes with user utility. Interestingly, market outcomes exhibit misalignment not only when the platforms have separate data repositories, but also when the platforms have a shared data repository. Nonetheless, the data sharing assumptions impact what mechanism drives misalignment and also affect the specific form of misalignment (e.g. the quality of the best-case and worst-case market outcomes). More broadly, our work illustrates that competition in digital marketplaces has subtle consequences for user utility that merit further investigation.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- Competing Bandits: The Perils of Exploration Under CompetitionACM Transactions on Economics and Computation, 2025
- Competing with Big Data*The Journal of Industrial Economics, 2021
- Learning, Experimentation, and Information Design2017
- Social Learning in One-Arm Bandit ProblemsEconometrica, 2007
- Strategic Experimentation with Exponential BanditsEconometrica, 2005
- Strategic Experimentation: the Undiscounted Case2000
- Strategic ExperimentationEconometrica, 1999
- Asymptotically efficient adaptive allocation rulesAdvances in Applied Mathematics, 1985
- Bandit Processes and Dynamic Allocation IndicesJournal of the Royal Statistical Society Series B: Statistical Methodology, 1979
- The Concept of Monopoly and the Measurement of Monopoly PowerReview of Economic Studies, 1934