In recent years, the growing expansion of short-term rentals and Airbnb listings has had significant impacts on urban environments, raising concerns about conflicts with long-term residents, both in qualitative terms (i.e. insecurity, quality of life) and in quantitative terms (i.e., house prices). This study investigates the impact of Airbnb diffusion on residential property prices in ten medium-to-large Italian cities with strong tourism appeal (Milan, Bergamo, Venice, Bologna, Florence, Rome, Bari, Lecce, Naples, and Palermo) over the period 2012–2022. Using a neighborhood-level panel dataset that combines real estate price data (Idealista.it) with georeferenced Airbnb listings (Inside Airbnb), we estimate hierarchical longitudinal multilevel models with random intercepts at both the city and neighborhood levels, controlling for demographic, income, tourism, and spatial factors. Results suggest a positive and statistically significant association between the intensity of short-term rentals—particularly the supply of entire-home listings—and housing sale prices. The effect is stronger in central neighborhoods, in Centre–North cities, and in urban areas characterized by a mixed tourism profile (cultural and business), where demand is more diversified and less seasonal. Moreover, a higher prevalence of multi-host operators, indicative of a more professionalized short-term rental market, is associated with further increases in property values. These findings underscore the substantial influence of short-term rentals on the real estate market and suggest that increased regulatory measures, similar to those in cities like Barcelona and Florence, may be needed to mitigate the effects of Airbnb on the real estate market itself.