A Comparison of Inversion Methods for Surrogate‐Based Groundwater Contamination Source Identification With Varying Degrees of Model Complexity
Open Access
- 28 March 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Water Resources Research
- Vol. 60 (4)
Abstract
Accurate identification of groundwater contamination sources is important for designing efficacious site remediation strategies. Currently, the methods for identifying contamination sources mainly fall into three distinct categories: simulation optimization, Bayesian inference, and data assimilation. Each method has its own advantages and disadvantages under specific site conditions. To evaluate the applicability of these methods, we chose one representative inversion algorithm from each category, namely the Improved Butterfly Optimization Algorithm (IBOA) for simulation optimization, the Ensemble Smoother with Multiple Data Assimilation (ES‐MDA) for data assimilation, and the DiffeRential Evolution Adaptive Metropolis with a Snooker Update and Sampling from a Past Archive (DREAM (ZS) ) for Bayesian inference. We conducted a comprehensive evaluation of these methods' performance under different model complexities, employing a surrogate model as a substitute for the complex forward model. By addressing two distinct problems involving conservative pollutant transport and Light Non‐Aqueous Phase Liquid (LNAPL) transport with biodegradation, we employed four criteria (elapsed time, result accuracy, posterior probability distribution, and noise resistance) for evaluation. The findings unequivocally indicate that DREAM (ZS) outperforms others in terms of result accuracy and posterior probability distribution. It also adeptly navigates the interrelations among disparate unknown variables. The strength of ES‐MDA lies in its efficiency. It achieves relatively satisfactory results with a reduced computational burden. In contrast, IBOA underperforms in both test problems. In terms of resistance to noise, both DREAM (ZS) and ES‐MDA perform better than IBOA does.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Natural Science Foundation of China (42377045)
- National Natural Science Foundation of China (42207062)
This publication has 59 references indexed in Scilit:
- Identifying groundwater contaminant sources based on a KELM surrogate model together with four heuristic optimization algorithmsAdvances in Water Resources, 2020
- An adaptive Gaussian process-based iterative ensemble smoother for data assimilationAdvances in Water Resources, 2018
- An Iterative Local Updating Ensemble Smoother for Estimation and Uncertainty Assessment of Hydrologic Model Parameters With Multimodal DistributionsWater Resources Research, 2018
- A Reduced‐Order Successive Linear Estimator for Geostatistical Inversion and its Application in Hydraulic TomographyWater Resources Research, 2018
- Simultaneous identification of a contaminant source and hydraulic conductivity via the restart normal-score ensemble Kalman filterAdvances in Water Resources, 2018
- Joint identification of contaminant source location, initial release time, and initial solute concentration in an aquifer via ensemble Kalman filteringWater Resources Research, 2016
- An adaptive Gaussian process‐based method for efficient Bayesian experimental design in groundwater contaminant source identification problemsWater Resources Research, 2016
- Efficient Bayesian experimental design for contaminant source identificationWater Resources Research, 2015
- Principal Component Geostatistical Approach for large‐dimensional inverse problemsWater Resources Research, 2014
- A sparse grid based Bayesian method for contaminant source identificationAdvances in Water Resources, 2012