Benchmark computation and performance evaluation for a rhombic plate bending problem
Authors:
- 1 January 1989
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in International Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering
- Vol. 28 (1) , 155-179
Abstract
The paper addresses the question of the accuracy and reliability of the computational analysis of the rhombic plate problem. The Kirchhoff model has a large error (measured in the energy norm) in comparison with the three dimensional solution with a soft simple support; also for very thin plates (t = 1/100a) and all angles (up to α = 90°). The Reissner–Mindlin model gives results 3–5 times better and is less sensitive to the change of the plate angle. The Kirchhoff model is a relatively good approximation of three dimensional setting for a hard simple support. The paradoxical (polygon) behaviour of the simply supported Kirchhoff plate extends to the Reissner–Mindlin model with a hard support. The finite element solution of the Kirchhoff model is addressed in detail. It is shown that higher degree methods are clearly preferable and that the skewness of the elements does not influence essentially the accuracy of the method; the singularity of the solution, which strongly depends on the skewness of the plate, is the primary cause of the deterioration of the performance of the FEM.Keywords
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- Regularity of the Solution of Elliptic Problems with Piecewise Analytic Data. Part I. Boundary Value Problems for Linear Elliptic Equation of Second OrderSIAM Journal on Mathematical Analysis, 1988
- The Optimal Convergence Rate of the p-Version of the Finite Element MethodSIAM Journal on Numerical Analysis, 1987
- Recent Progress in the Two-Dimensional Approximation of Three - Dimensional Plate Models in Nonlinear Elasticity1987
- The h-p version of the finite element methodComputational Mechanics, 1986
- An evaluation of skew sensitivity of thirty three plate bending elements in nineteen FEM systemsNuclear Engineering and Design, 1985
- A proposed standard set of problems to test finite element accuracyFinite Elements in Analysis and Design, 1985
- On the Angle Condition in the Finite Element MethodSIAM Journal on Numerical Analysis, 1976
- Sur la methode des elements finis hybrides pour le probleme biharmoniqueNumerische Mathematik, 1975
- BENDING OF A SIMPLY SUPPORTED RHOMBIC PLATE UNDER UNIFORM NORMAL LOADINGQuarterly Journal of Mechanics and Applied Mathematics, 1962
- Herleitung der plattentbeorie aus der dreidimensionalen elastizitätstheorieArchive for Rational Mechanics and Analysis, 1959