Performance appraisal, employee development and organizational justice: exploring the linkages
- 1 July 2005
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The International Journal of Human Resource Management
- Vol. 16 (7) , 1176-1194
Abstract
Much has been written about performance appraisal (PA) in such a manner as to suggest that the process is politically driven, even though one of its primary purposes is said to be the development of the individual employee. Our examination of a cross-section of workers' perceptions of this process was therefore motivated by the need to determine whether they believed that they experienced fair outcomes from PA, and whether its usage was seen to contribute toward their career advancement. Given the role unions are expected to play in shaping human resource outcomes, we hypothesized that workers in the non-union environment would experience lower levels of procedural and interactional justice than their trade-union counterparts. We also hypothesized that, since unions might be asked to walk a tightrope in contesting PA decisions affecting different persons who were union members, employers would be able to exercise much discretion in making those decisions, with the result that there would not be any appreciable difference in justice perceptions between union member and non-union member. A third hypothesis that informed the research was that workers' perceptions about the treatment received from performance appraisal were likely to influence their expectations regarding career advancement, as expressed through opportunities for training and development, pay for performance and promotions. No significant differences in perception were found among union and non-union respondents' perceptions about the vast majority of procedural elements used in this study. Contrary to our hypothesis, non-union respondents expressed less unfavourable perceptions about the interactional elements than their trade-union counterparts. The results confirmed the hypothesis that workers who believed that performers were not treated fairly as a result of performance appraisal would also agree that their expectations regarding development and advancement were not being met. We found significant, but relatively moderate relationships between perceptions about treatment of performers and their expectations about career advancement.Keywords
This publication has 21 references indexed in Scilit:
- HRM and service fairness: How being fair with employees spills over to customersOrganizational Dynamics, 1999
- WORKPLACE JUSTICE AND JOB SATISFACTION AS PREDICTORS OF SATISFACTION WITH UNION AND MANAGEMENT.Academy of Management Journal, 1989
- EFFECTS OF PROCEDURAL AND DISTRIBUTIVE JUSTICE ON REACTIONS TO PAY RAISE DECISIONS.Academy of Management Journal, 1989
- Causal Accounts and Managing Organizational ConflictCommunication Research, 1988
- Interactional fairness judgments: The influence of causal accountsSocial Justice Research, 1987
- The role of procedural and distributive justice in organizational behaviorSocial Justice Research, 1987
- A Taxonomy of Organizational Justice TheoriesAcademy of Management Review, 1987
- Why employees want unionsOrganizational Dynamics, 1980
- Inequity In Social Exchange1965
- Towards an understanding of inequity.The Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 1963