Saucerization Versus Complete Resection of a Symptomatic Discoid Lateral Meniscus at Short‐ and Long‐term Follow‐up: A Systematic Review
- 1 September 2017
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Wiley in Arthroscopy
- Vol. 33 (9) , 1733-1742
Abstract
Purpose: To evaluate the surgical outcomes of symptomatic discoid menisci after total meniscectomy, saucerization, and suture repair of tears of a discoid meniscus at short‐ and long‐term follow‐up. Methods: A systematic review was conducted using the Pubmed and ScienceDirect databases in adherence with Preferred Reporting Items of Systematic Reviews and Meta‐Analysis guidelines. Short‐ and long‐term follow‐up were defined as an average follow‐up of 4 years, respectively. Pooled quantitative synthesis was performed on studies that reported results of total meniscectomy and saucerization in the same study. A systematic review was performed on studies that reported data on saucerization, total meniscectomy, and/or repair. Results: A total of 19 studies for the short term and 22 for the long term were identified that met inclusion criteria for qualitative review. Of these, 4 short‐term and 5 long‐term studies were included in the quantitative synthesis. No significant differences in Ikeuchi scores are seen in the short‐term studies between saucerization and total meniscectomy; however, the long‐term studies did find a statistical difference favoring saucerization ( P < .001). The differences noted between the preoperative and postoperative Lysholm scores in the short term were 24.1 (95% conflict of interest: 10.25‐37.95) in 3 studies and 22.38 (95% conflict of interest: 17.68‐27.07) in the 4 long‐term studies for saucerization. Suture repair with saucerization versus saucerization without suture repair revealed a statistical difference in only 1 of 5 studies. Conclusions: Long‐term data demonstrate significantly improved patient reported outcomes in favor of saucerization over total meniscectomy. Suture repair of tears of a lateral discoid meniscus does not demonstrate improved outcomes over partial meniscectomy without repair. Considering the cost of repair and lack of demonstrated improvement, based on the limited available data, we do not recommend repair of the abnormal anatomy in a torn lateral discoid meniscus. Level of Evidence: Level IV, systematic review.Keywords
This publication has 46 references indexed in Scilit:
- Results of Arthroscopic Partial Meniscectomy for Lateral Discoid Meniscus Tears Associated with New TechniqueKnee Surgery & Related Research, 2013
- Management and outcome of discoid meniscus tearsFormosan Journal of Musculoskeletal Disorders, 2011
- Results of Subtotal/Total or Partial Meniscectomy for Discoid Lateral Meniscus in ChildrenArthroscopy, 2009
- Arthroscopic Resection of the Discoid Lateral Meniscus: Long‐term Follow‐up for 16 YearsArthroscopy, 2006
- Torn discoid lateral meniscus treated using partial central meniscectomy and suture of the peripheral tearArthroscopy, 2004
- Arthroscopic treatment of the discoid lateral meniscus: Results of long‐term follow‐upArthroscopy, 1989
- Lateral discoid menisci in childrenArthroscopy, 1989
- Meta-analysis in clinical trialsControlled Clinical Trials, 1986
- Meniscal tears: The effect of meniscectomy and of repair on intraarticular contact areas and stress in the human kneeThe American Journal of Sports Medicine, 1986
- Meniscectomy in children: A long-term follow-up studyThe American Journal of Sports Medicine, 1983