Malaria over-diagnosis in Cameroon: diagnostic accuracy of Fluorescence and Staining Technologies (FAST) Malaria Stain and LED microscopy versus Giemsa and bright field microscopy validated by polymerase chain reaction
Authors:
- Sean M. ParselSPSean M. Parsel
- Steven A. GustafsonSGSteven A. Gustafson
- Edward FriedlanderEFEdward Friedlander
- Alexander A. ShnyraASAlexander A. Shnyra
- Aderosoye J. AdegbuluAAAderosoye J. Adegbulu
- Ying LiuYLYing Liu
- Nicole M. ParrishNPNicole M. Parrish
- Syed A. JamalSJSyed A. Jamal
- Eve LofthusELEve Lofthus
- Leo AyukLALeo Ayuk
- Charles AwasomCACharles Awasom
- Carolyn J. HenryCHCarolyn J. Henry
Open Access
- 4 April 2017
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Infectious Diseases of Poverty
- Vol. 6 (1) , 1-9
Abstract
Malaria is a major world health issue and its continued burden is due, in part, to difficulties in the diagnosis of the illness. The World Health Organization recommends confirmatory testing using microscopy-based techniques or rapid diagnostic tests (RDT) for all cases of suspected malaria. In regions where Plasmodium species are indigenous, there are multiple etiologies of fever leading to misdiagnoses, especially in populations where HIV is prevalent and children. To determine the frequency of malaria infection in febrile patients over an 8-month period at the Regional Hospital in Bamenda, Cameroon, we evaluated the clinical efficacy of the Flourescence and Staining Technology (FAST) Malaria stain and ParaLens AdvanceTM microscopy system (FM) and compared it with conventional bright field microscopy and Giemsa stain (GS). Peripheral blood samples from 522 patients with a clinical diagnosis of “suspected malaria” were evaluated using GS and FM methods. A nested PCR assay was the gold standard to compare the two methods. PCR positivity, sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV), and negative predictive value (NPV) were determined. Four hundred ninety nine samples were included in the final analysis. Of these, 30 were positive via PCR (6.01%) with a mean PPV of 19.62% and 27.99% for GS and FM, respectively. The mean NPV was 95.01% and 95.28% for GS and FM, respectively. Sensitivity was 26.67% in both groups and specificity was 92.78% and 96.21% for GS and FM, respectively. An increased level of diagnostic discrepancy was observed between technicians based upon skill level using GS, which was not seen with FM. The frequency of malarial infections confirmed via PCR among patients presenting with fever and other symptoms of malaria was dramatically lower than that anticipated based upon physicians’ clinical suspicions. A correlation between technician skill and accuracy of malaria diagnosis using GS was observed that was less pronounced using FM. Additionally, FM increased the specificity and improved the PPV, suggesting this relatively low cost approach could be useful in resource-limited environments. Anecdotally, physicians were reluctant to not treat all patients symptomatically before results were known and in spite of a negative microscopic diagnosis, highlighting the need for further physician education to avoid this practice of overtreatment. A larger study in an area with a known high prevalence is being planned to compare the two microscopy methods against available RDTs.Keywords
Funding Information
- Kansas City University of Medicine and Biosciences
- QBC Diagnostics
- Shumaker Foundation
This publication has 36 references indexed in Scilit:
- Two Techniques for Simultaneous Identification of Plasmodium ovale curtisi and Plasmodium ovale wallikeri by Use of the Small-Subunit rRNA GeneJournal of Clinical Microbiology, 2012
- LED Fluorescence Microscopy for the Diagnosis of Pulmonary Tuberculosis: A Multi-Country Cross-Sectional EvaluationPLOS Medicine, 2011
- Novel Nested Direct PCR Technique for Malaria Diagnosis Using Filter Paper SamplesJournal of Clinical Microbiology, 2011
- Usefulness of the Paralens™ Fluorescent Microscope Adaptor for the Identification of Mycobacteria in Both Field and Laboratory SettingsThe Open Microbiology Journal, 2010
- Rapid diagnostic tests compared with malaria microscopy for guiding outpatient treatment of febrile illness in Tanzania: randomised trialBMJ, 2007
- Clinical algorithms for malaria diagnosis lack utility among people of different age groupsTropical Medicine & International Health, 2005
- Diagnosis and Treatment of Malaria in ChildrenClinical Infectious Diseases, 2003
- A review of practical techniques for the diagnosis of malariaPathogens and Global Health, 1998
- Direct acridine orange fluorescence examination of blood slides compared to current techniques for malaria diagnosisTransactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, 1996
- Accuracy of routine laboratory diagnosis of malaria in the United Kingdom.Journal of Clinical Pathology, 1994