What value do formally stated environmental objectives add when managers can also observe what the organization actually does? Building on strategy-process research and drawing on sensemaking and social identity theories, we examine how two forms of corporate environmental sustainability (CES) engagement—CES strategic objectives (e.g., mission and vision statements) and CES practices—shape employees’ understanding of organizational goals and proactive behavior. CES strategic objectives function as espoused signals of environmental purpose; CES practices function as enacted cues of commitment through routines and resource allocations. Using survey data from 24,915 managers in 302 Brazilian companies and an online experiment with U.S. managers, we find that CES practices enhance proactive behavior through goal clarity and pride, while CES strategic objectives do not independently do so. However, objectives strengthen the practices–goal clarity relationship, promoting proactive behavior. These findings clarify when declaring green matters for doing green, showing that the behavioral value of CES strategic objectives is mechanism-specific.