Observational intensity bias associated with illness adjustment: cross sectional analysis of insurance claims
Authors:
- J. E. WennbergJWJ. E. Wennberg
- D. O. StaigerDSD. O. Staiger
Open Access
Abstract
Objective To determine the bias associated with frequency of visits by physicians in adjusting for illness, using diagnoses recorded in administrative databases. Setting Claims data from the US Medicare program for services provided in 2007 among 306 US hospital referral regions. Design Cross sectional analysis. Participants 20% sample of fee for service Medicare beneficiaries residing in the United States in 2007 (n=5 153 877). Main outcome measures The effect of illness adjustment on regional mortality and spending rates using standard and visit corrected illness methods for adjustment. The standard method adjusts using comorbidity measures based on diagnoses listed in administrative databases; the modified method corrects these measures for the frequency of visits by physicians. Three conventions for measuring comorbidity are used: the Charlson comorbidity index, Iezzoni chronic conditions, and hierarchical condition categories risk scores. Results The visit corrected Charlson comorbidity index explained more of the variation in age, sex, and race mortality across the 306 hospital referral regions than did the standard index (R2=0.21 v 0.11, Pv 56.3 deaths per 1000, PConclusion The rates of visits by physicians introduce substantial bias when regional mortality and spending rates are adjusted for illness using comorbidity measures based on the observed number of diagnoses recorded in Medicare’s administrative database. Adjusting without correction for regional variation in visit rates tends to make regions with high rates of visits seem to have lower mortality and lower costs, and vice versa. Visit corrected comorbidity measures better explain variation in age, sex, and race mortality than observed measures, and reduce observational intensity bias.Keywords
This publication has 23 references indexed in Scilit:
- 25 year trends in first time hospitalisation for acute myocardial infarction, subsequent short and long term mortality, and the prognostic impact of sex and comorbidity: a Danish nationwide cohort studyBMJ, 2012
- Risk Adjustment of Medicare Capitation Payments Using the CMS-HCC Model2004
- Explaining differences in English hospital death rates using routinely collected dataBMJ, 1999
- Chronic conditions and risk of in-hospital death.1994
- Geographic Variation in Expenditures for Physicians' Services in the United StatesNew England Journal of Medicine, 1993
- Can hospital use be a measure of need for health care?Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 1987
- ARE HOSPITAL SERVICES RATIONED IN NEW HAVEN OR OVER-UTILISED IN BOSTON?The Lancet, 1987
- A new method of classifying prognostic comorbidity in longitudinal studies: Development and validationJournal of Chronic Diseases, 1987
- Will Payment Based on Diagnosis-Related Groups Control Hospital Costs?New England Journal of Medicine, 1984
- Professional uncertainty and the problem of supplier-induced demandSocial Science & Medicine, 1982