Getting the dose–response wrong: why hormesis became marginalized and the threshold model accepted
- 21 February 2009
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Springer Nature in Archives of Toxicology
- Vol. 83 (3) , 227-247
Abstract
The dose–response relationship is central to the biological and biomedical sciences. During the early decades of the twentieth century consensus emerged that the most fundamental dose–response relationship was the threshold model, upon which scientific, health and medical research/clinical practices have been based. This paper documents that the scientific community made a fundamental error on the nature of the dose response in accepting the threshold model and in rejecting the hormetic-biphasic model, principally due to conflicts with homeopathy. Not only does this paper detail the underlying factors leading to this dose response decision, but it reveals that the scientific community never validated the threshold model throughout the twentieth century. Recent findings indicate that the threshold model poorly predicts responses in the low dose zone whereas its dose response “rival”, the hormesis model, has performed very well. This analysis challenges a key foundation upon which biological, biomedical and clinical science rest.Keywords
This publication has 154 references indexed in Scilit:
- Another California Milestone: The First Application of Hormesis in Litigation and RegulationInternational Journal of Toxicology, 2008
- Are Radiation-Induced Effects Hormetic?Science, 1989
- A model of two functionally antagonistic receptor populations activated by the same agonistJournal of Theoretical Biology, 1977
- AUREOMYCIN: A PRODUCT OF THE CONTINUING SEARCH FOR NEW ANTIBIOTICSAnnals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 1948
- STIMULATIVE EFFECTS OF X-RAYS ON PLANT GROWTHPlant Physiology, 1933
- Toxic Inorganic Salts and Acids as Affecting Plant Growth (Preliminary Communication)Botanical Gazette, 1913
- The Toxic Action of Certain Organic Plant ConstituentsBotanical Gazette, 1908
- Toxic Limits and Stimulation Effects of Some Salts and Poisons on WheatBotanical Gazette, 1907
- The Effect of Ether Upon the Germination of Seeds and SporesBotanical Gazette, 1899
- On the Toxic Action of Dissolved Salts and Their Electrolytic DissociationBotanical Gazette, 1896