Power and precision of invasive carp ichthyoplankton sampling along an invasion front
Open Access
- 26 November 2025
- journal article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in North American Journal of Fisheries Management
- Vol. 46 (1) , 40-57
Abstract
Objective: Detecting changes in the abundance of invasive fish species is valuable for assessing population trends and creating management plans. Although many programs focus on adult relative abundance to estimate population dynamics, assessments of early life stages can provide insights into reproductive success that are not detectable from adult surveys. However, early ichthyoplankton catches are often highly variable and guidelines are needed on detectable percentages of change and the sample sizes that are required for desired precision. We evaluated larval surveys of invasive carp (Silver Carp Hypophthalmichthys molitrix and Bighead Carp H. nobilis) across 7 years in the upper Mississippi River basin to assess the statistical precision and effectiveness of detecting fluctuations in the relative abundance of invasive carp larvae. Methods: We sampled invasive carp in the upper Mississippi River and five tributaries from 2014 to 2019 and 2021. Sampling occurred biweekly from April through September at 30 sites spanning established, invasion, and presence fronts of the current carp distribution. Each site was sampled with three larval tows using a 0.5-m-diameter ichthyoplankton net. We evaluated the maximum annual larval densities (high-output spawning events) and mean densities (baseline spawning activity), calculating the coefficient of variation (CV) as our precision metric. We used generalized linear models to test how environmental factors affected sampling variability. We determined the relationship between the sample means and variability and then calculated the sample sizes that are needed to achieve CV = 0.30. Power analyses estimated the sampling effort that would be required to detect percentages of change in larval densities. Results: We captured invasive carp larvae in 72 of 4,462 larval tows. The mean larval carp densities ranged from 1.4 to 2,869.3 carp/100 m3 (mean = 77.3, median = 7.5), with mean interreplicate variance of 60,461. Three tows per sample returned a CV of 1.46 (SE = 0.06), indicating low precision. Achieving CV = 0.30 required an average of 57 samples. Sampling CV was positively associated with river discharge and negatively associated with water temperature. Conclusions: Sampling exhibited extreme variability with zero-inflated data, as most tows captured no larvae and 50% of the successful captures detected larvae in only one of three replicates. Environmental factors significantly influenced precision, with CV positively associated with discharge and negatively with temperature. Sampling location affected precision, with the lowest CV in established populations and the highest in invasion areas. Achieving acceptable precision (CV < 0.30) required approximately 60 tows per site. The values for maximum annual densities provided better statistical power than did those for the mean densities, reducing the required sample sizes by nearly 50% at some sites. However, both metrics showed low statistical power, with required sampling effort largely unattainable. We recommend that managers consider these statistical challenges when designing monitoring programs and supplement ichthyoplankton sampling with complementary methods like environmental DNA to improve detection efficiency, particularly in invasion-front areas.Keywords
Funding Information
- U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (GR-024708-00001)
This publication has 75 references indexed in Scilit:
- Differences in Native and Invasive Fish Larval Occupancy and Detection Probabilities in the Upper Mississippi RiverRiver Research and Applications, 2025
- Effects of bigheaded carp on larval Freshwater Drum dietsTransactions of the American Fisheries Society, 2023
- Intra-Annual Variability of Common Carp and Bigmouth Buffalo Electrofishing Data in Shallow LakesNorth American Journal of Fisheries Management, 2023
- Plasticity in Reproductive Potential of Bigheaded Carp along an Invasion FrontNorth American Journal of Fisheries Management, 2021
- Suitability of an Upper Mississippi River Tributary for Invasive Carp ReproductionNorth American Journal of Fisheries Management, 2021
- Comparison of Active and Passive Larval Sampling Gears in Monitoring Reproduction of Invasive Bigheaded Carps in Large-River TributariesNorth American Journal of Fisheries Management, 2020
- Invasive Carp Reproduction Phenology in Tributaries of the Upper Mississippi RiverNorth American Journal of Fisheries Management, 2020
- Evaluation of Unbaited Hoop Nets for Simultaneously Assessing Channel Catfish and Flathead Catfish populations in the Minnesota RiverNorth American Journal of Fisheries Management, 2018
- Larval fish catches in the lower Milk River, Montana in relation to timing and magnitude of spring dischargeRiver Research and Applications, 2008
- Coefficient of Variation1998