Between Sweet Harmony and a Clash of Cultures: Does a Joint Academic–Practitioner Review Reconcile Rigor and Relevance?
- 28 December 2010
- journal article
- review article
- Published by SAGE Publications in The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science
- Vol. 47 (1) , 53-75
Abstract
A substantial body of literature discusses the so-called rigor—relevance gap in management science and possible ways of overcoming it. A frequently advocated approach, in line with Gibbons, Limoges, Nowotny, Schwartz, and Trow’s “Mode 2” idea of creating “hybrid fora,” is the introduction of joint academic—practitioner review processes in management journals. In an empirical case study of one of the oldest management journals in the world, the authors show that the demands of academic and practitioner reviewers are hardly compatible, and, to some extent, inversely correlated. In contrast to other studies, here the authors show that the reason for the tension between academics and practitioners with regard to this issue does not lie in differences in the evaluation criteria of each group. Rather, the different worldviews of academics and practitioners lead to different interpretations of these criteria and a striking incongruence between the two groups’ ideas of practical relevance.Keywords
This publication has 49 references indexed in Scilit:
- That’s Relevant! Different Forms of Practical Relevance in Management ScienceOrganization Studies, 2010
- Introduction to the Special Issue: Organization Studies as a Science for Design: Creating Collaborative Artifacts and ResearchOrganization Studies, 2008
- On the Relationship Between Research and PracticeJournal of Management Inquiry, 2007
- Perceived Causes and Solutions of the Translation Problem in Management ResearchAcademy of Management Journal, 2007
- Bringing the Design Sciences to Organization Development and Change ManagementThe Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 2007
- Management Research as a Design Science: Articulating the Research Products of Mode 2 Knowledge Production in ManagementBritish Journal of Management, 2005
- Are managers from Mars and academicians from venus? Toward an understanding of the relationship between academic quality and practical relevanceStrategic Management Journal, 2004
- Users and unicorns: a discussion of mythical beasts in interactive scienceScience and Public Policy, 2000
- `Relevance' in Management ResearchManagement Learning, 1998
- Toward an Applied Administrative ScienceAdministrative Science Quarterly, 1983