Quality Appraisal of Nutritional Guidelines to Prevent, Diagnose, and Treat Malnutrition in All Its Forms during Pregnancy
Authors:
- Cinthya Muñoz-ManriqueCMCinthya Muñoz-Manrique
- Mónica Ancira-MorenoMAMónica Ancira-Moreno
- Soraya Burrola-MéndezSBSoraya Burrola-Méndez
- Isabel Omaña-GuzmánIOIsabel Omaña-Guzmán
- Elizabeth Hoyos-LoyaEHElizabeth Hoyos-Loya
- Sonia Hernández-CorderoSHSonia Hernández-Cordero
- Alejandra Trejo-DomínguezATAlejandra Trejo-Domínguez
- Mónica MazariegosMónica Mazariegos
- Natalia SmithNSNatalia Smith
- Scarlett Alonso-CarmonaScarlett Alonso-Carmona
- Jennifer Mier-CabreraJMJennifer Mier-Cabrera
- Loredana Tavano-ColaizziLTLoredana Tavano-Colaizzi
Open Access
Abstract
This work aimed to identify clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) that include recommendations for the prevention, diagnosis, and treatment of women’s malnutrition during pregnancy and to evaluate the quality of these guidelines using the Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation (AGREE II) instrument. We conducted a literature review using PubMed and different websites from January 2009 to February 2021. The quality of the CPGs was independently assessed by reviewers using the AGREE II instrument, which defines guidelines scoring >70% in the overall assessment as “high quality”. The analysis included 43 guidelines. Among the main findings, we identified that only half of the CPGs (51.1%) obtained a final “high quality” evaluation. AGREE II results varied widely across domains and categories. The two domains that obtained the highest scores were scope and purpose with 88.3% (range 39 to 100%) and clarity of presentation with 87.2% (range 25 to 100%). Among the “high quality” CPGs, the best scores were achieved by the three guidelines published by the National Institute of Health and Care Excellence (NICE) and the World Health Organization (WHO). Due to the importance of maternal nutrition in pregnancy, it is essential to join forces to improve the quality of the guidelines, especially in CPGs that do not meet the reference standards for quality.Keywords
Funding Information
- United Nations Children’s Fund (RFP9156422)
This publication has 58 references indexed in Scilit:
- Gestational weight gain and long-term postpartum weight retention: a meta-analysisThe American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 2011
- AGREE II: Advancing guideline development, reporting, and evaluation in health carePreventive Medicine, 2010
- Scoping studies: advancing the methodologyImplementation Science, 2010
- Development of the AGREE II, part 1: performance, usefulness and areas for improvementCanadian Medical Association Journal, 2010
- Significant haemoglobinopathies: guidelines for screening and diagnosisBritish Journal of Haematology, 2010
- Guidelines for the diagnosis and management of aplastic anaemiaBritish Journal of Haematology, 2009
- Practice Parameter update: Management issues for women with epilepsy—Focus on pregnancy (an evidence-based review): Vitamin K, folic acid, blood levels, and breastfeedingNeurology, 2009
- Position of the American Dietetic Association and American Society for Nutrition: Obesity, Reproduction, and Pregnancy OutcomesJournal of the American Dietetic Association, 2009
- Maternal and child undernutrition: consequences for adult health and human capitalThe Lancet, 2008
- Scoping studies: towards a methodological frameworkInternational Journal of Social Research Methodology, 2005