Statistical Pitfalls in Brain Age Analyses
Authors:
- Ellyn R. ButlerEBEllyn R. Butler
- Andrew An ChenACAndrew An Chen
- Rabie RamadanRRRabie Ramadan
- Trang T. LeTLTrang T. Le
- Kosha RuparelKRKosha Ruparel
- Tyler M. MooreTMTyler M. Moore
- Theodore D. SatterthwaiteTSTheodore D. Satterthwaite
- Fengqing ZhangFZFengqing Zhang
- Haochang ShouHSHaochang Shou
- Ruben C. GurRGRuben C. Gur
- Thomas E. NicholsTNThomas E. Nichols
- Russell T. ShinoharaRSRussell T. Shinohara
Preprint
Abstract
Over the past decade, there has been an abundance of research on the difference between age and age predicted using brain features, which is commonly referred to as the “brain age gap”. Researchers have identified that the brain age gap, as a linear transformation of an out-of-sample residual, is dependent on age. As such, any group differences on the brain age gap could simply be due to group differences on age. To mitigate the brain age gap’s dependence on age, it has been proposed that age be regressed out of the brain age gap. If this modified brain age gap (MBAG) is treated as a corrected deviation from age, model accuracy statistics such as R 2 will be artificially inflated. Given the limitations of proposed brain age analyses, further theoretical work is warranted to determine the best way to quantify deviation from normality. Highlights: The brain age gap is an out-of-sample residual, and as such varies as a function of age. A recently proposed modification of the brain age gap, designed to mitigate the dependence on age, results in inflated model accuracy statistics if used incorrectly. Given these limitations, we suggest that new methods should be developed to quantify deviation from normal developmental and aging trajectories.Keywords
This publication has 31 references indexed in Scilit:
- Multimodality neuroimaging brain-age in UK biobank: relationship to biomedical, lifestyle, and cognitive factorsNeurobiology of Aging, 2020
- Ten Years of BrainAGE as a Neuroimaging Biomarker of Brain Aging: What Insights Have We Gained?Frontiers in Neurology, 2019
- Bias-adjustment in neuroimaging-based brain age frameworks: A robust schemeNeuroImage: Clinical, 2019
- Use of Machine Learning to Determine Deviance in Neuroanatomical Maturity Associated With Future Psychosis in Youths at Clinically High RiskJAMA Psychiatry, 2018
- Incorrect Inferences When Using Residuals as Dependent VariablesJournal of Accounting Research, 2018
- Towards a unified analysis of brain maturation and aging across the entire lifespan: A MRI analysisHuman Brain Mapping, 2017
- Brain age predicts mortalityMolecular Psychiatry, 2017
- Imaging Patterns of Brain Development and their Relationship to CognitionCerebral Cortex, 2014
- Evolving Knowledge of Sex Differences in Brain Structure, Function, and ChemistryBiological Psychiatry, 2007
- Statistic Notes: Regression towards the meanBMJ, 1994