Using word embedding models to capture changing media discourses: a study on the role of legitimacy, gender and genre in 24,000 music reviews, 1999–2021
Open Access
- 16 September 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Computational Social Science
- Vol. 5 (2) , 1615-1636
Abstract
Studies suggest that popular music genres are increasingly discussed by cultural intermediaries in ‘legitimate’ or ‘highbrow’ terms, rather than merely ‘lowbrow’ commercial entertainment. In addition, popular music discourse as produced by such intermediaries has historically been decidedly masculine—a trait which tends to increase on par with legitimation. However, seeing that women are gradually gaining symbolic and numerical representation in popular music production, this may have been changing over the last decade(s). In this article, we assess how popular music discourse within a key music media outlet (Pitchfork) changed between 1999 and 2021. We use word embedding models—a novel technique in computational social science—to assess legitimacy and gender in the discourses used in 23,992 reviews, and how this varies between genres. We find four notable patterns. First, reviews increasingly use a discourse that legitimates popular music, while, second, also increasingly using more feminine terms. This does not, third, occur simultaneously; however, discourse is either legitimate or feminine. Finally, these patterns also differ based on which popular music genres are discussed. The overall pattern is consistently found in pop, electronic and experimental, but not in historically masculine genres rap/hip-hop, metal and jazz which seem rather resistant to discursive change.Keywords
This publication has 68 references indexed in Scilit:
- The impact of peer-produced criticism on cultural evaluation: A multilevel analysis of discourse employment in online and offline film reviewsNew Media & Society, 2013
- Gender and Cultural Consecration in Popular MusicSocial Forces, 2010
- The Evaluation of Popular Music in the United States, Germany and the Netherlands: A Comparison of the Use of High Art and Popular Aesthetic CriteriaCultural Sociology, 2010
- Cultural Globalization and Arts Journalism: The International Orientation of Arts and Culture Coverage in Dutch, French, German, and U.S. Newspapers, 1955 to 2005American Sociological Review, 2008
- Youth cultural stylesYoung, 2008
- Young People's Musical Taste: Relationship With Gender and Gender‐Related Traits1Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 2008
- Canadian content regulations and the formation of a national scenePopular Music, 2008
- Critical Discourse and the Cultural Consecration of American FilmsSocial Forces, 2004
- WHEN WOMEN PLAY THE BASSGender & Society, 1999
- "Anything But Heavy Metal": Symbolic Exclusion and Musical DislikesAmerican Sociological Review, 1996