Evaluating Evidence‐Based Practice and Quality Improvement Initiatives in the Nursing Literature Using a Critical Appraisal Tool
Open Access
- 12 August 2026
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Nursing Scholarship
- Vol. 58 (5)
Abstract
Introduction: Reports of evidence‐based practice (EBP) and quality improvement (QI) in nursing journals often vary in reporting quality, hindering translation into practice. A critical appraisal tool for evidence‐based practice quality improvement (EBPQI) has recently been made available on the EQUATOR Network. Methods: A descriptive cross‐sectional study of full‐length articles (Jan–Jun 2025) from 28 nursing journals that accept reports of EBP and/or QI (per submission guidelines); each article was scored by two authors using the open‐access critical appraisal tool for EBPQI. Results: Collectively, these journals published 86 issues and 949 full‐length articles; 30 (3.2%) articles were identified as EBP or QI reports and were published among 10 (33%) journals. Of these 30 articles, only 6 (20%) used appropriate EBP and/or QI methods and were therefore appraised using the EBPQI critical appraisal tool. Based on the EBPQI critical appraisal tool, the EBP and QI reports varied in how and to what extent they met EBPQI criteria. Conclusion: Variation exists in journal guidance and reporting of EBP/QI initiatives. Consistent use of EBPQI criteria highlights the need for standardized reporting to improve transparency, transferability, and translation into practice. Clinical Relevance: Transparent, standardized reporting of EBP and/or QI initiatives enables clinicians to appraise relevance and transferability to practice. Reporting aligned with recognized guidelines (or clear justification for deviations) is warranted.Keywords
This publication has 12 references indexed in Scilit:
- Optimizing research-to-practice translation time through the mountain model: A Delphi studyNursing Outlook, 2026
- Misalignment between research and quality improvement terminology in published nursing reports: A descriptive studyNursing Outlook, 2026
- Evidence-Based Practice Policy Analysis and Program Evaluation Reporting GuidelinesJournal of Nursing Care Quality, 2025
- Evidence-Based Practice Quality Improvement Reporting GuidelinesJournal of Nursing Care Quality, 2025
- Appropriate Use of Statistical Analysis in DNP ProjectsThe Journal for Nurse Practitioners, 2025
- Appropriate Use of Evidence-Based Practice Quality Improvement and Research Methods, Designs, and TerminologyJournal of Nursing Care Quality, 2025
- Evidence-Based Practice Quality Improvement Critical Appraisal ToolJournal of Nursing Care Quality, 2024
- The quality of clinician and student quality improvement reports: An analysis of 8 years of submissionsJournal of Nursing Scholarship, 2024
- The Mountain Model for Evidence-Based Practice Quality Improvement InitiativesAJN, American Journal of Nursing, 2024
- Evidence-Based Practice: Step by Step: The Seven Steps of Evidence-Based PracticeAJN, American Journal of Nursing, 2010